Greater Hartford/ Community & Society

Hartford's Bushnell Apologizes After Gay Couple Left Out of Anniversary Shout-Out

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Hartford's Bushnell Apologizes After Gay Couple Left Out of Anniversary Shout-OutAsylum Hill Congregational Church — Site of Couple's 2022 Wedding
Google Street View

Rev. Darrell Goodwin and Kentavis Goodwin-Brice went to The Bushnell’s Belding Theater on November 7 to celebrate their wedding anniversary during a sold-out performance by violinist John Randolph. When the musician invited anniversary couples in the crowd to stand and be recognized, the Hartford couple rose with everyone else. Goodwin says they were the only ones skipped.

The Bushnell issued its apology Monday night, nine days after the performance, following criticism on social media over the couple’s exclusion. According to the Hartford Courant, the venue said it had spoken directly with Goodwin and Goodwin-Brice, acknowledged that the exclusion was deeply hurtful, and committed to maintaining a welcoming, respectful and safe environment for every patron. The Bushnell said it plans to continue its conversation with the couple going forward.

Randolph, known for his violin interpretations of R&B, soul and contemporary music, recognized other anniversary-celebrating couples in the audience but passed over Goodwin and Goodwin-Brice. “Everyone around us was acknowledged. Except us,” Goodwin wrote in a Facebook post quoted by Queerty. The couple says other audience members offered support and congratulations as the moment unfolded, but they ultimately left the performance feeling excluded.

A Private Apology, a Refund Offer, and a Request to Meet

Goodwin requested a refund and an apology from The Bushnell afterward. He told the outlet that Randolph responded privately with an apology, “and the Bushnell has also offered an apology and a promise for a refund.” Randolph’s apology, as relayed to the same publication, said the couple deserved to feel acknowledged and celebrated, always. Both the violinist and the venue have since offered to meet with the couple directly.

Goodwin distinguished between being excluded and merely feeling excluded. He said he and his husband were humiliated when their marriage was treated as invisible, and that the repeated framing of relationships as exclusively between men and women during the show deepened their sense of exclusion. He added that while Randolph is gifted, talent does not excuse behavior that leaves people feeling dehumanized. Goodwin also thanked the strangers in the audience who stood up for the couple in the moment.

Who the Couple Is

Goodwin serves as president of the Southern New England Conference of the United Church of Christ and sits on the Bloomfield Town Council. Goodwin-Brice works as a social worker, adjunct professor, and program coordinator with Connecticut’s Department of Children and Families. The two married in 2022 at Asylum Hill Congregational Church in Hartford, a ceremony the church’s senior ministers said was its first Black gay wedding.

The couple had opened that wedding to the public, inviting people to attend and offering a livestream for those who could not be there in person. As the Hartford Courant reported at the time, those unable to attend in person could watch the ceremony via livestream. Goodwin said the decision to open their wedding to the public was an act of activism meant to interrupt the absence of images of Black, gay love, particularly within the context of faith.

In the years since, Goodwin says he and Goodwin-Brice have received both messages of support and messages of hate because of their visibility as a couple. Reflecting on the latest incident, Goodwin said love will prevail and that their love will never be invisible.