
A Highland County resident handed over $19,000 in cash to a stranger who showed up at his home in a black Toyota SUV, convinced he was protecting his bank accounts from fraud. Instead, investigators say, he was the one being robbed. Two Florida men have now been sentenced to prison for orchestrating the scheme.
Leon Raynard Brown and Cecil Silvester Arnold, both of Locka, Florida, pleaded guilty Nov. 5 in Highland County Common Pleas Court to third-degree felony aggravated theft from a person in a protected class by deception, according to the Scioto Valley Guardian. Each man was sentenced to 12 months in prison and ordered to pay restitution.
The case began Dec. 1, 2025, when deputies responded to a residence in Brushcreek Township, the outlet reports. The victim told investigators he’d been contacted by people posing as representatives of First State Bank’s fraud department, who claimed his accounts had been compromised and instructed him to withdraw cash to protect it.
Cash Handed Off in a Black Toyota SUV
Believing he had no choice, the victim withdrew a total of $19,000 from banks in Winchester and Hillsboro after being told a federal agent would come to his home to collect the money. On Nov. 27, 2025, someone arrived at his residence in a black Toyota SUV and picked up the cash, the same report states.
Investigators determined that the driver who collected the money had unknowingly been hired to transport it, believing it was a legitimate delivery job rather than part of a theft scheme. That detail became a key thread as detectives worked to trace the cash back to its source.
Tracking Suspects From Ohio to Florida
Detectives pieced together vehicle video, hotel records, airline records and airport surveillance footage to identify Brown and Arnold as the men behind the scheme, with help from the Milford Police Department, CVG Airport and the Hamilton County Heroin Task Force, per the Scioto Valley Guardian’s reporting. A Highland County grand jury eventually indicted both men, who were extradited from Florida to face the charges.
Under Ohio law, the deception at the heart of the case involves knowingly deceiving another person, or causing someone to be deceived, through false or misleading representations, withholding information, or other conduct that creates a false impression, according to the Ohio Revised Code. That standard underpins the aggravated theft charge both men admitted to.
Sheriff’s Office Says It’s Not an Isolated Case
The sheriff’s office said similar cash-pickup scams have targeted other residents in the region, suggesting the Highland County case fits a broader pattern rather than a one-off incident. Officials warned that financial institutions and government agencies will never ask customers to withdraw large sums and hand cash to strangers, or buy gift cards, to resolve account fraud. They advised anyone who receives such a request to stop communicating immediately and contact their financial institution directly.
The tactic echoes a nationwide surge in so-called gold-courier and cash-pickup schemes. The FBI reported in 2025 that the gold-courier scam alone drained more than $300 million from victims nationally, according to 13abc. The Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions has said the scam is surging and frequently targets seniors, often using couriers to collect cash or valuables in person.
In one case described by the same outlet, a Wisconsin woman said scammers persuaded her to spend $131,208 on 24 gold coins before a courier collected them from her. She ultimately reported losing more than $400,000 of her retirement savings after scammers impersonated federal agencies, her investment company and the Better Business Bureau. The Highland County case, while far smaller in dollar terms, followed the same basic playbook: manufactured urgency, a false authority figure, and an in-person cash handoff designed to avoid the scrutiny of a bank wire or check.









