Chicago/ Community & Society

Hobart Humane Society Pushes New Shelter Plan After Derecho Flooded Old One

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Hobart Humane Society Pushes New Shelter Plan After Derecho Flooded Old One2054 IN-130 — Hobart Shelter Plan Location
Google Street View

The Humane Society of Hobart has been sheltering animals in the same building since 1954, and this year that 72-year-old facility took on roughly eight inches of water during the August derecho, forcing staff to scramble for temporary housing for the animals inside. Now the organization is pressing ahead with plans for a new shelter, leaning on a feasibility study, a land search, and efforts to establish a regional coalition of animal welfare groups to get there.

The flooding added urgency to a problem the shelter had already been flagging for months. Executive director Jennifer Webber has described the current building's cinder block as crumbling, as reported by the Chicago Tribune, which covers the shelter's location at 2054 E. Indiana 130 and the wider territory it serves across Hobart and parts of Lake and Porter counties. The shelter also carries the highest animal intake among a five-county area in northwest Indiana, according to the same report.

Webber has said the shelter now posts a 98% live-release rate and has saved nearly 20,000 animals over the past eight years, a dramatic swing from 2018, when she said the shelter had the highest kill rate among the five counties it was then compared against. Intake numbers from 2026 show just how much territory the shelter covers beyond Hobart itself: 243 animals came from Gary, 240 from Lake Station, 135 from Merrillville and about 100 from Portage. Roughly 70% of all animals taken in come from outside Hobart, based on intake data cited in the Tribune's reporting.

A Feasibility Study, Not Yet a Fundraising Campaign

The shelter has a feasibility study underway to determine whether a new facility is financially and operationally workable, and it is seeking a land donation to make that possible. Webber has said the organization is currently seeking perspective rather than donations on acquiring land and building what she envisions as a combined pet family resource center and animal shelter, with shared space for other animal welfare groups and nonprofits. The proposed facility would include a walking trail, outdoor gathering spaces, and resources and services aimed at pet-owning families.

That vision builds on groundwork laid earlier this year. The Tribune reported in May that the shelter was hoping to find 10 to 15 acres for a new facility that would include an outdoor area for staff and the public to walk dogs, plus a resource campus with veterinary care — essentially the same framework Webber is now describing as the feasibility study moves forward. In August, Hobart's Board of Public Works unanimously approved a $237,000 donation agreement with the shelter, which the Tribune's reporting shows Mayor Josh Huddlestun said was meant to help the organization get the ball rolling, including on a capital campaign feasibility study. The city also agreed to help expedite needed permitting and approvals and to waive applicable permit fees, with the expectation that the shelter would use the funds within a year of receiving them.

Building a Regional Coalition

The shelter isn't tackling this alone. On Nov. 30, the Humane Society of Hobart will join Dogs 4 U and Hydrant Pet Center in hosting the inaugural NWICAP Leadership Mixer from 5:30 to 8:30 p.m. at Byway Brewing Company in Hammond, with dinner and a welcome beverage provided at no charge. The mixer is meant to establish a coordinated regional coalition of animal welfare professionals, bringing together shelters, rescues, veterinary professionals, animal control agencies, municipal leaders, public health representatives, businesses and community organizations.

The planned coalition aims to strengthen emergency preparedness, professional development, resource sharing and pet-retention programs, and attendees at the mixer will be asked to weigh in on governance, membership, committee structure and first-year priorities. Niki Hitt, marketing director of Hydrant Pet Center, said the coalition would connect existing community organizations and resources and give participants a voice in shaping future work. The three organizing groups also recently shared a $13,000 immediate mission support grant from the Crown Point Community Foundation.

Pressure From Every Direction

The push for a new building comes against a backdrop of strain that predates this year's flooding. In 2023, Webber pointed to a nationwide trend of more animals entering shelters while fewer get adopted, tying it to economic pressures like rising costs and a shortage of veterinarians, according to Lakeshore Public Media. At that time, the shelter held contracts to provide animal-control services to Hobart, Lake Station and New Chicago, and Webber said the facility had capacity for 29 dogs but was housing close to 60. The organization also said it planned to begin billing outside communities for animals brought in from beyond its jurisdiction.

The numbers behind that strain go back further still. Pet Friendly Services of Indiana reported that the shelter's overall live-release rate was just 67% in 2017 before climbing to 98.9% in 2019, a turnaround it has maintained ever since. That same organization noted that in 2022 alone, the shelter pulled more than 800 dogs from other facilities that were full and where those dogs were at risk of euthanasia. The shelter expects to provide resources to more than 5,000 pets and their families in 2026, a scale of need that underscores why Webber and her partners are now looking well beyond Hobart's borders for both land and allies.

Amid the planning and the paperwork, there are still quieter moments at the shelter. On a sunny Monday afternoon, Lee Rademacher played acoustic guitar for the dogs housed there — a small scene that captures what staff are trying to protect as they push toward something bigger and sturdier than the cinder-block building that has sheltered Hobart's animals since 1954.