Chicago/ Sports

Illinois Public Schools Push IHSA to Split Football Playoffs From Private Powerhouses

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Illinois Public Schools Push IHSA to Split Football Playoffs From Private PowerhousesSource: Dave Adamson / Unsplash

Illinois' debate over public and private school football playoffs centers on how teams earn postseason places. The West Suburban Conference says all 14 of its member schools are asking the Illinois High School Association to establish separate public- and private-school postseasons statewide.

The IHSA is weighing two bylaw proposals that would change how teams qualify for the state series. According to NBC Chicago, the association was set to decide within days whether to recommend separating public and private schools; high schools statewide would then make the final call in early December. A membership vote on the proposals that reach the ballot is scheduled for November 30 through December 14, per Shaw Local.

Two Competing Proposals on the Table

One plan, identified by the Chicago Tribune as Proposal No. 8, would establish separate postseasons for private schools in sports with three or more classes. In football, Shaw Local reports, the eight existing classes would be divided into six for public schools and two for private and non-boundary schools.

Proposal 15 would instead reserve one of four semifinal places for a private or non-boundary school, leaving three for public schools. Shaw Local reports that private and non-boundary schools earned 46 semifinal bids over the past five seasons, including 10 in 2022, a figure supporters cite in backing the proposal.

Why Public Coaches Say the System Is Tilted

Buffalo Grove High School head football coach Jeff Vlk, who supports separate postseasons, argues the core issue is that public schools have no control over their rosters. “As a public league coach, you don't get to choose what comes through your door,” Vlk told NBC Chicago, adding that most public-school coaches believe private schools hold an unfair advantage because, as the outlet put it, private schools can recruit players from anywhere.

Illinois already tries to account for enrollment gaps through its classification system, including eight football classes and a 1.65 enrollment multiplier applied during the regular season, according to the same NBC Chicago report. That multiplier traces to IHSA By-Law 3.170, which the Illinois High School Association says must be applied to every non-boundaried school's enrollment — though the association notes that applying it does not necessarily bump a school into a higher classification, and individual sport or activity programs can receive waivers on a two-year basis.

How Illinois Has Adjusted Classification

The IHSA says it first applied a 1.65 enrollment multiplier to non-boundaried schools’ postseason classifications in fall 2005. The association describes the multiplier as a way to determine the class in which a school competes in postseason tournaments.

Ohio offers a historical precedent for the separation debate, though its votes were not Illinois decisions: members of the Ohio High School Athletic Association rejected proposals to split public and non-public tournaments in 1978 and 1993, according to the Springfield News-Sun.

Private Schools Push Back

Nazareth Academy head football coach and dean of students Tim Racki, whose program plays in the Chicago Catholic League and has won six state football titles all-time, rejects the idea that private schools have it easy. Racki points out that private schools like his receive no state funding and must charge tuition to operate, while public schools offer free attendance and strong facilities of their own.

Racki also told NBC Chicago that the CCL-ESCC would consider leaving the IHSA if public and private schools were placed in separate series. He said competing against stronger opponents helps programs improve.

A Classification Line That Disappears in the Playoffs

Boundaried and non-boundaried schools already operate under different enrollment models heading into the season, but that distinction largely disappears once teams enter the state series, according to the reporting. The West Suburban Conference contends that different recruitment structures competing in the same qualification process can create an uneven playing field in bracketed team sports, and the conference says its proposal addresses competitive equity within the state series while still giving boundaried schools what it calls meaningful postseason opportunities.

The championship results are part of the argument over competitive balance. NBC Chicago reported that private schools won five of Illinois' eight state football championships in 2025 and seven of eight in 2024. Private schools make up about 80 of the roughly 500 Illinois high schools that play football. Vlk also pointed to the difference in roster sizes, comparing a Class 1A school with 25 varsity players to a Class 7A school with 50 to 70.

A Debate That Has Simmered for Years

This isn't a new argument. Debates over perceived advantages private schools hold in IHSA athletics continued through the 2025 state football championships, according to WGLT. That outlet reported that three of the eight 2025 championship matchups pitted a public school against a private one — and the private school won every single time. The IHSA itself told WGLT last year that it was against separating the divisions, stating flatly, “We are very much against having split divisions.”

Part of the IHSA's resistance may come down to math. WGLT's reporting noted that private schools make up just 12% of Illinois schools, which sports reporter Steve Soucie cited as a structural challenge to carving out a standalone private-school classification system.

How Other States Have Handled the Split

Illinois wouldn't be breaking new ground if it moves forward — nine other states already separate public and private school playoffs, according to NBC Chicago. A broader look from Yahoo Sports found four states operate under a fully split model, while five more use partial splits that separate schools for certain playoffs, championships, or brackets. The remaining 41 states combine public and private schools, often leaning on enrollment multipliers or competitive-balance formulas instead.

Those systems haven't been without friction elsewhere. Yahoo Sports reported that Alabama's athletic association voted 13-2 to split public and private schools for championships while still keeping them together during the regular season. In Nevada, 30 members of that state's athletic association reportedly chose to go independent rather than face private schools, and in New York, several schools moved down to a lower tier specifically to avoid a particular private school in their region.

What Comes Next

Any changes to Illinois' postseason structure would also run alongside existing IHSA eligibility rules that already prohibit recruiting high school students for athletics or offering athletic scholarships and other special benefits tied to sports participation, according to the association's 2025–2026 eligibility summary. Students found to have been recruited to enroll or transfer for athletic purposes risk losing eligibility under those same rules.

For now, the fate of both proposals rests with IHSA member schools. The statewide membership vote between November 30 and December 14 will determine whether Illinois joins the list of states with a divided postseason — or whether, as the IHSA signaled last year, the state series stays unified for public and private programs alike.