Greater Des Moines/ Crime & Emergencies

Iowa Court Upholds Conviction of Ex-UNI Student Who Threatened to Shoot Dean

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Iowa Court Upholds Conviction of Ex-UNI Student Who Threatened to Shoot DeanUniversity of Northern Iowa — Reported University At Center Of Case
Google Street View

The Iowa Court of Appeals has rejected an appeal from a former University of Northern Iowa student convicted of threatening to shoot a campus dean, affirming her conviction and finding that sufficient evidence supported the charge. The ruling, handed down Wednesday, closes off a bid by Aisha Nyala to overturn a conviction that has already sent her to prison once and back to a residential correctional facility after her probation was revoked.

The appeals court's decision affirms Nyala's conviction for intimidation with a dangerous weapon, according to the Waterloo-Cedar Falls Courier. A judge warned Nyala that a probation violation could trigger a 10-year prison sentence. Her probation was later revoked.

On appeal, Nyala challenged the trial judge's failure to order a competency hearing. The appellate court found the evidence sufficient to support the underlying charge, rejecting her bid to have the conviction thrown out.

How the Threats Against the Dean Began

The case traces back to allegations that Nyala used a fake Facebook profile to send multiple threatening messages to UNI Dean of Students Allyson Rafanello and her husband, Nick Rafanello, according to court documents cited by KCCI. The outlet reported that Nyala allegedly told the Iowa Board of Regents she was “going to come to the University and shoot that woman” in the head if action wasn't taken within two days.

Nyala was charged with three counts of stalking by use of a technological device, five counts of first-degree harassment, and intimidation with a dangerous weapon, per the same KCCI report. KCRG reported that she was found guilty of intimidation with a dangerous weapon after threatening to kill the dean in January 2024.

Claims of Assault and a Tuition Dispute

Nyala also alleged that she had been sexually assaulted by a UNI employee. Nyala also sought reimbursement of her tuition, according to the paper's reporting, though the outcome of that request was not detailed.

With the appeal now rejected, Nyala's conviction stands as decided at trial. The case was handled in Black Hawk County, where Nyala's underlying proceedings played out before the matter reached the Iowa Court of Appeals this week.