Minneapolis/ Crime & Emergencies

Lake Benton Firefighter Charged After Confessing He Set Bar Fire He Later Fought

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Lake Benton Firefighter Charged After Confessing He Set Bar Fire He Later FoughtLake Benton Fire Department — Department Responding To Bar Fire
Google Street View

A volunteer firefighter in the small town of Lake Benton, Minnesota is facing felony charges after investigators say he confessed to breaking into a local bar, lighting paper and cardboard on fire in the basement, and then showing up to help fight the blaze he started. Jameson John Vermaat has been charged with second-degree arson and criminal property damage in connection with the July fire at Homer's Bar & Grill.

According to Dakota News Now, the criminal complaint states that Vermaat told investigators he broke into the bar and set fire to paper and cardboard in the basement. The complaint also says Vermaat responded to the fire as a member of the Lake Benton Fire Department, meaning the volunteer firefighter allegedly answered the call to battle the same fire he had set. Dakota News Now reported the case on November 13, 2026, before Firehouse.com published its report on November 20, 2026.

Physical Evidence Pointed Investigators to the Scene

Investigators reportedly found an orange pipe wrench and possible ignition sites in the basement of the bar, according to the station's report. That wrench turned out to be a key piece of evidence: it matched the make and color of wrenches carried on trucks belonging to the local fire department, and smoke patterns indicated it was already at the scene before the fire started.

Investigators initially suspected a disgruntled employee of Homer's Bar & Grill may have been behind the fire, but the same account notes that theory was ruled out because a number of valuable items inside the bar were left untouched. That detail, combined with the wrench matching fire department equipment, appears to have redirected the investigation toward someone with access to the department's tools.

A Confession During a November Interview

Per the station's reporting, Vermaat admitted during a November 6 interview that he lit the fire, responding simply, “Yes,” when asked. He reportedly told investigators he was intoxicated at the time and did not think the fire would cause as much damage as it did.

A judge set bail at $45,000 without conditions, or alternatives of a $30,000 bond or $3,000 cash with conditions, per the earlier report. Vermaat's next court appearance was scheduled for Nov. 19 in Ivanhoe, though the evidence reviewed for this story does not confirm whether that hearing took place or what, if anything, resulted from it.