
The Florence County Election Commission has denied a protest from Lake City Mayor Yamekia Robinson, upholding former Mayor Larue Alford's victory in the Nov. 3 mayoral race and rejecting Robinson's bid for a runoff. Commissioners reported Alford took 785 votes to Robinson's 584 and Michael Donavan Nero's 530 — with no candidate crossing the halfway mark of total votes cast.
The commission's decision, handed down Friday, leaves former Mayor Larue Alford poised to return to office despite Robinson's argument that Lake City's election ordinance requires a majority winner and, since no one reached one, demands another election. According to WPDE, the city had maintained all along that no runoff was necessary, pointing to South Carolina Code Section 5-15-61 as the governing law for its nonpartisan plurality system — the method under which whoever gets the most votes wins outright, majority or not. Notably, the vote totals reported by the commission differ from the unofficial returns that circulated right after election night, when HereFlorence reported Alford with 773 votes, Robinson with 575 and Nero with 526; the dossier does not explain the shift between the two counts.
A Timeline Shaped by a Technicality
Robinson filed her formal protest on Nov. 6, the same day the commission certified the Nov. 3 results, the station's report notes. Commissioners then heard arguments from Robinson and from Alford's attorney, Marion Fowler, before deliberating behind closed doors in executive session.
Fowler leaned hard on a 2015 South Carolina Supreme Court ruling, Mitchell v. City of Greenville, telling commissioners it should guide how they read Lake City's own ordinance. Per the same account, that decision upheld Greenville's adoption of nonpartisan plurality elections even though an attachment to its ordinance contained conflicting runoff language — the court reportedly found Greenville's ordinance showed a clear intent to use the plurality method and effectively struck the conflicting runoff text from the attachment. Fowler argued that same legislative intent should settle Lake City's dispute in Alford's favor.
Fowler Says Robinson Had Prior Notice
Fowler didn't stop at case law. He called Florence County Council member Jason Springs as a witness, who testified about confusion over Lake City's election ordinance that had already surfaced during a 2024 election — an unresolved issue, Springs said, that could have settled the voting-method question long before this year's contest came to a head.
Fowler argued Robinson was on notice, or should have been, about that same conflicting ordinance language well before the 2026 race, saying she was included on an email chain discussing the issue ahead of the 2024 election. Robinson, for her part, said she was indeed on that chain but had expected the city administrator at the time and the city's attorney to handle the matter, telling commissioners the administrator never placed it on a city council meeting agenda. Fowler countered that letting Robinson's protest succeed now would effectively give her, in his words, two bites of the apple.
Robinson Called a Past Administrator to the Stand
Robinson brought her own witness, former Lake City administrator George Simmons, who testified that he remembered the city's election process as one that simply awarded victory to whichever candidate got the most votes. Robinson also cited a January 2005 executive order from then-Governor Mark Sanford directing a runoff for Lake City's District 5 city council seat, though that order concerned a council district race rather than the mayoral contest now in dispute. The commission noted the 2005 runoff had been delayed past its required timeframe because of protest hearings tied to the November 2004 election.
Commission Finds Ordinance Unclear, Results Stand Anyway
In the end, commissioners agreed the city's election code was unclear but ruled that the ambiguity did not jeopardize the outcome of the vote, as reported by The Post and Courier. That finding let Alford keep his win intact even as the underlying legal question about which election method Lake City is actually supposed to use remains unsettled.
Lake City's position tracks with a public statement the city issued days after the election. WMBF News reported that on Nov. 4, city staffers announced no runoff election was planned, weeks before the commission's hearing made that position official. The dispute centers on South Carolina Code Section 5-15-61 and Lake City's ordinance, but which election method governs the city remains unsettled.
Robinson said her intention now is to appeal the commission's decision, according to the same WPDE report that first detailed the ruling. Whether that appeal will be filed, and what it might change, remains to be seen.









