
Nearly two years after Los Angeles Unified School District rolled out bell-to-bell cellphone restrictions, a new districtwide survey shows the policy is landing very differently depending on how old you are. More than 160,000 students and over 21,000 staff members weighed in on LAUSD's spring 2026 school experience survey, and student responses on whether the policy improved focus were split nearly evenly.
A Generational Split on Focus
Nearly 58% of middle school students told the district they focused better in class all or most of the time without their phones, according to LAist. Fewer than half of high schoolers said the same. Staff perceptions tracked a similar pattern, with middle school staff estimating that about two-thirds of their students mostly followed the restrictions, while high school staff pegged compliance at just over half among their students, the outlet reported.
LAUSD implemented the bell-to-bell restrictions in February 2025, giving schools the choice of buying lockable pouches, installing lockers, or simply relying on an honor system to keep phones out of students' hands during the school day. That flexibility means enforcement has looked different from campus to campus, and the new survey data offers the first public quantitative look at how students and staff think it's actually going.
Test Scores Rose, But Timing Matters
LAUSD students' standardized reading and math scores have climbed over the past three years, but those gains began before the district's cellphone ban took effect, the same report noted. That timing detail matters for anyone hoping to credit the phone restrictions directly with academic improvement in Los Angeles — the survey measured focus and behavior, not a causal link to test scores.
National research on school phone bans tells a more complicated story depending on which study you read. A new analysis in the New York Times looked at 3.3 million students in grades three through 10 across 4,600 U.S. schools between 2021 and 2026, comparing fall-to-spring MAP test results at schools with strict phone bans against similar schools without them. That study found math and reading scores improved by an amount equivalent to roughly one or two additional weeks of school per year at schools requiring full-day phone lockups.
Other Research Finds Smaller or Mixed Effects
A separate national study cited in the LAist report reached a different conclusion, finding close to zero effect on test scores and attendance, though it did find about 30% fewer GPS pings measured on campuses three years after a phone ban began, along with disciplinary incidents that rose in a policy's first year before declining in later years. Researchers tied to the National Bureau of Economic Research studied a Florida urban school district and found no statistically significant test-score change in the ban's first year, followed by an average increase of 1.1 percentiles in year two. That same Florida district saw student suspensions rise 25% in September 2023 compared with the prior year, with elevated disciplinary rates persisting through the full school year — though the researchers also reported significant reductions in unexcused absences, and said increased attendance could explain as much as half of the measured test-score gains.
The same Florida study, published as NBER Working Paper 34388, found that cellphone-ban effects were more pronounced in middle and high schools, where smartphone ownership is more common. Taken together, the research suggests outcomes vary by district, by grade level, and by how strictly a ban is enforced — a pattern that lines up with LAUSD's own split results between its middle and high schoolers.
The Price Tag on Enforcement
Keeping phones out of students' hands hasn't been cheap. LAUSD spent about $6.35 million on cellphone-policy products during the 2024-25 school year, including $5.42 million on Yondr pouches and nearly $930,000 on Amazon products such as phone lockers, per the LAist report. Schools were given latitude to choose which enforcement method fit their campus, from locking pouches to simple storage lockers to an honor-system approach that relies on students following the rules without physical barriers.
A Statewide Mandate Is Coming
California's own policy framework is also evolving. Bill text reviewed from the California Legislature states that district, county, and charter-school governing boards must develop and adopt a policy by July 1, 2026, to limit or prohibit students' smartphone use at school or while under school employees' supervision, and must update that policy every five years.
Public sentiment elsewhere suggests restrictions are gaining acceptance even as questions about effectiveness persist. A 2026 survey cited by the Canadian survey brief found support for school phone restrictions reached an all-time high of 87%, up from 81% the year before — though only 45% of respondents in that same survey considered the restrictions at least somewhat effective, while 41% viewed them as ineffective. For LAUSD, with its own sharply divided student feedback between middle and high schoolers, that same tension between broad support and uncertain payoff appears to be playing out locally, nearly two years into the bell-to-bell experiment.









