Southwest Florida/ Politics & Govt

Marco Island's New Council Moves to Grab Back Power Over Big Projects

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Marco Island's New Council Moves to Grab Back Power Over Big ProjectsMarco Island City Council — Site of Council Power Debate
Google Street View

Marco Island's brand-new City Council wasted no time signaling where it stands on development oversight. At its first meeting with the newly elected board seated, six of seven members agreed by consensus to direct City Attorney Alan Gabriel to draft an amendment that would claw back the Council's final say over site development plans — a power it gave up five years ago.

There was no formal vote behind the move. According to Florida Politics, newly sworn-in Council Chair Rick Woodworth announced that “six out of seven” members agreed by consensus to have Gabriel draft the amendment, but no motion or roll call was taken. Woodworth had already written a memo to the Council dated Nov. 5 asking that the amendment get its first reading at the earliest available meeting, though no date has been set for Gabriel's draft to come back before the board.

The push traces directly back to the 2026 election. On Nov. 3, Dennis Bartolucci, Teri Sommerfeld and Woodworth swept all three open Council seats after campaigning together on a residents-first message and openly opposing the Rose Marina and Hilton expansion proposals, per Florida Politics' reporting. Sommerfeld was sworn in as vice chair and Bartolucci as a council member, while Woodworth was elected chair by a 6-1 vote over Bartolucci. The three will serve four-year terms alongside four councilors elected in 2024, according to the Naples Daily News.

What Ordinance 21-10 Actually Changed

The target of the new amendment is Ordinance 21-10, adopted by the Council on Sept. 7, 2021. That rule shifted the Planning Board's role on site development plans from merely recommending to the Council to having final decision-making authority, the Florida Politics report notes. Before that ordinance, every site plan went before the full Council for a decision.

Under the current system, Council review only kicks in on appeal — and only if the applicant or an affected property owner files one within 14 days of a Planning Board decision. Site-plan amendments below a 10% threshold bypass the Council entirely and go straight to staff, the same report states. Woodworth has described the proposal as restoring Council authority to correct what he views as mistakes baked into the 2021 ordinance, and has said Marco Island voters showed they want final project-development decisions returned to the elected board. He has floated returning all site plans to the Council, with minor items potentially routed to a consent agenda where they could still be pulled for individual review.

Woodworth, who is retired after spending most of his career in real estate development and management, moved to Marco Island full time in 2017, according to the Naples Daily News. City Manager Casey Lucius, chosen for the permanent manager position in May, has previously told a prior Council that criteria for deciding which plans return to its members would be difficult to define and enforce, and suggested the board could instead weigh an all-or-nothing approach.

Rose Marina and the Hilton Became the Flashpoints

Two development fights this summer and fall turned into the backdrop for the new Council's push. The Planning Board approved Rose Marina's site development plan on July 23 for a 200-seat restaurant, additional parking and reconfigured docks at 951 Bald Eagle Drive, Florida Politics reported. Eight days later, on July 31, the same board took up the Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort and Spa's request to rezone its roughly 10.5-acre property, which would have added a second tower, a parking garage and a second restaurant while growing the hotel from 310 rooms to 626.

Accounts of that July 31 Hilton vote differ. Florida Politics reported the Planning Board recommended Council approval by a 3-2 margin, while the Naples Press described the Planning Commission approving the rezoning 6-1 at a special hearing. Because Rose Marina's plan became final under Ordinance 21-10's rules, the Council's role was limited to a marathon September session over variances and a conditional use permit tied to the project.

That meeting ran until 12:55 a.m. on Sept. 10, when the Council finally approved Rose Marina's variances and conditional use permit by a 4-2 vote, with Tamara Goehler and Stephen Gray dissenting, according to Marco Island's local paper. During that same late-night session, then-Council member Rene Champagne said he would propose requiring Council review of projects with community-wide impact, and Gray committed to carrying the discussion into the next Council term.

A Compromise That Never Came, Then a Withdrawal

The Hilton rezoning dragged on through the fall. At a Sept. 22 meeting, the Council continued its consideration of the request, and Hilton representatives agreed with city staff to work on a compromise proposal for presentation in October, per the earlier Marco Island reporting on the matter. City staff had recommended denial of the rezoning outright, and Planning Board member Jason Bailey had voted against the recommendation back in July.

Champagne formally proposed sending larger projects to the Council while leaving routine applications with the Planning Board at an Oct. 5 meeting, arguing the Council should address community concerns about major projects directly. Fellow Council member Darrin Palumbo supported considering an added safeguard while still emphasizing the Planning Board's expertise, and Bonita Schwan suggested leaving the decision to the incoming Council rather than act before the election. In the end, no ordinance change was adopted that night.

The Hilton ultimately withdrew its rezoning request on Oct. 16, just three days before the Council was scheduled to hear it, Florida Politics reported. Neither Champagne nor fellow Council member Kevin Dohm ran for reelection, and both Palumbo and Bailey lost their respective election bids on Nov. 3 — clearing the way for the residents-first trio now pushing the Ordinance 21-10 rewrite.

What's Still Unresolved

No text of the proposed amendment has surfaced publicly, and nothing in the record indicates when it might return to the Council for a first reading or a vote. The direction given at the new Council's first meeting was a consensus, not a formal motion or roll-call vote, and city staff continue to process other site plans under the existing rules in the meantime — including a 45-unit condo-hotel and 45-slip marina proposed for 3200 San Marco Road, which the Planning Board approved by a 4-1 vote with Chair Bailey dissenting, according to a report from Citizen Portal.