Memphis/ Crime & Emergencies

Memphis Family Says Judge Suppressed Confession in Watermelon Man Case

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 14, 2026
Memphis Family Says Judge Suppressed Confession in Watermelon Man CaseHomer St. & Wayne Ave. — Approximate Site of Watermelon Seller Shooting
Google Street View

John Materna's family says the judge handling his accused killer's case has thrown out a key piece of evidence: the suspect's confession.

Materna was the Memphis fruit vendor affectionately called the Watermelon Man. FOX13 Memphis reported Nov. 14 that the family described feeling devastated and outraged after saying the judge suppressed that evidence.

Shot While He Was Working

Materna was shot on the job on May 15, 2023, at the corner of Homer Street and Wayne Avenue. He died at the hospital two weeks later, Action News 5 reported.

A February 2024 FOX13 report said Demarion Tackett, then 16, allegedly admitted to the shooting at that corner. He was charged with first-degree murder. FOX13 has identified him as the teenage suspect accused of killing Materna.

Adult Court and a Much Higher Bond

The case was transferred to adult court. Judge Jennifer Mitchell then released Tackett on a $100,000 bond in March 2024, Action News 5 reported.

He later missed court and was captured by U.S. Marshals, the station reported that July. In August 2024, a judge set a $1.2 million bond after hearing arguments from the state. The reporting did not say that judge was Mitchell.

What the Family Says Happened to the Confession

FOX13 attributes the suppression claim to Materna's family, not to a quoted ruling. The family said the judge handling the suspect's case threw out a key piece of evidence, and the station's headline identifies that evidence as the confession.

That is the same alleged admission FOX13 described in 2024, when it reported that Tackett had admitted the shooting at Homer and Wayne. The family is now saying that statement is out of the case, and describing the result as devastating and outrageous.

Tackett remains the person charged with first-degree murder in Materna's death. The last bond figure in the reporting is the $1.2 million set in August 2024, after a release at $100,000 and a marshal capture that followed a missed court date.