
A Milwaukee County judge sentenced 19-year-old Jeremiah Taylor to life in prison this week for gunning down two teenagers on Christmas Day 2024, closing out a case that took nearly two years to reach a jury. Taylor was convicted in October of two counts of first-degree intentional homicide in the deaths of 15-year-old Exziel Rivera and 18-year-old Nayah Vasquez, who were killed near 37th and Scott in a shooting investigators tied to a planned marijuana purchase.
According to FOX6 News Milwaukee, the judge handed down the sentence on Nov. 12, making Taylor eligible for extended supervision only after he has served 50 years behind bars. Investigators said two groups of friends had planned to meet at 37th and Scott on Dec. 25, 2024, a gathering that ended in gunfire.
Gunfire Erupts During a Planned Drug Deal
Milwaukee police were dispatched to the shooting near 37th and Scott on Christmas Day, per the same fox6now.com account. Accounts of the exact timing vary: a Wisconsin circuit court criminal complaint places the dispatch at about 11:27 a.m., while CBS 58 reported the shooting happened around 11:30 a.m. near South 37th and West Scott streets. The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel has separately reported that neighbors heard gunshots around 11:25 a.m.
A occupant of the victims' Kia told police the group had arranged to buy marijuana and was told to stop and wait for the seller, according to the criminal complaint. That is when a black Malibu pulled alongside the Kia, and a passenger leaned out of the front window and fired a gun multiple times at the vehicle, the complaint states. The Kia then struck a parked car before rolling against a residential porch.
Two Teens Lost, Shooter Fled
Exziel Rivera was found with a gunshot wound to the head outside the SUV and was pronounced dead at the scene, while Nayah Vasquez was wounded by gunfire in the back seat and later died after being taken to a hospital, the fox6now.com report states. Police spoke with two people who had been inside the vehicle during the shooting; one occupant identified Jeremiah Taylor as the shooter and said there had been bad blood between the friend groups before the gunfire broke out.
Law enforcement recovered video from several cameras near the shooting scene and used that surveillance footage to identify two suspects. Quintarez Morris was arrested in connection with the case, the outlet reported. Officers located the black Malibu burned in Dineen Park later on Dec. 25, 2024, according to fox6now.com's account of the investigation.
From Reckless Homicide Charges to a Jury Conviction
Taylor went on the run after the shooting and was not arrested until July 22, 2025, per the same report. He and Morris were initially charged in January 2025 with two counts of first-degree reckless homicide as a party to a crime, according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. That charge carried a dangerous-weapon enhancer, per the criminal complaint.
By the time the case reached trial, prosecutors secured a jury conviction in October 2026 on the more serious counts of first-degree intentional homicide. The Journal Sentinel reported on the case in January 2025, when Taylor was still a fugitive; he pleaded not guilty in September 2025.
Nearly two years passed between the Christmas Day shooting and Taylor's sentencing this week, a span that included his months on the run, his eventual arrest, and the trial that led a jury to convict him. The case was built using records from the Milwaukee County District Attorney's Office and Wisconsin circuit court access, according to fox6now.com's reporting.









