Milwaukee/ Food & Drinks

Brady Street's Concoctions Closes Quietly, Owner Eyes Bay View or Downtown Next

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Brady Street's Concoctions Closes Quietly, Owner Eyes Bay View or Downtown Next1316 E. Brady St. — Closed Brady Street Storefront
Google Street View

Concoctions, the Caribbean cocktail bar and dessert spot that spent the last four years pouring tropical drinks and dipping strawberries in chocolate on Brady Street, has quietly closed its storefront, with owner Hyacinth Nembhardt now on the hunt for a new Milwaukee location.

According to Urban Milwaukee, Concoctions closed its storefront in the Passeggio building after four years of service on Brady Street, where it operated at 1316 E. Brady St. The outlet reports that the business had its last official day on October 31, per Nembhardt, who described the closure not as an ending but as a transition to a new chapter.

Nembhardt said the move feels right even though she doesn't yet have a new space lined up, according to the same report. She's reportedly hoping to secure a lease either downtown or in Milwaukee's Bay View neighborhood, and plans to relocate the brand from what had been a party-atmosphere storefront to a more family-friendly space.

From Liquor Store to Mobile Truck to Brick-and-Mortar

Concoctions' Brady Street chapter was just the latest stop in a business that Nembhardt has been reshaping for nearly two decades. She founded Concoctions in 2007, according to Milwaukee Magazine, before closing that first venue in 2009 and pivoting to selling specialty beverages at Jazz in the Park and other local festivals.

The brand resurfaced in 2017 when Nembhardt launched what the magazine's report calls Milwaukee's first mobile drink truck. From there, the business kept evolving: it started as a liquor store with specialty drinks to go, then became a mobile cocktail truck, and eventually a full-service bar, as OnMilwaukee has chronicled. At the end of 2020, Nembhardt opened a full-service and to-go bar at 4943 W. Fond du Lac Ave., where all of the drinks were available with or without alcohol. At that location, Nembhardt had a staff of six, with her daughter, Hyleah Pulley, serving as manager.

Cocktails, Boba and Slush Parties, For Now at Tropic

While Nembhardt searches for Concoctions' next permanent home, many of the brand's tropical drinks aren't disappearing from Milwaukee menus entirely. Per Urban Milwaukee, Tropic — a Caribbean restaurant and bar also owned by Nembhardt, located at 518 N. Water St. — is offering many of Concoctions' tropical drinks in the interim.

Concoctions built its following on customizable tropical drinks served with or without liquor, alongside specialty coffees, boba teas and fruit arrangements, the outlet's report notes. The business has also hosted Slush & Slime parties for children's birthdays and other special events, a detail that lines up with Nembhardt's stated goal of leaning the new location toward families rather than the nightlife crowd Brady Street drew.

Fruit Bouquets and Berries Still on the Menu

Even without a storefront, Concoctions says it will keep serving its specialty fruit bouquets while relocation plans develop, and that cocktails will continue at whatever location comes next, according to Urban Milwaukee's reporting. Nembhardt has said she wants a larger kitchen in the next space specifically to produce Sheri's Berries and fruit bouquets, the outlet reports.

Those desserts include chocolate-dipped fruit platters and cake pops, and on Concoctions' own site, the strawberries are described as generously dipped in rich chocolate, sprinkles and coconut, according to Concoctions' website. The same page advertises same-day delivery for orders placed by noon, with delivery promised by 8 p.m. Customers can still place orders directly on Concoctions' website even as the brand searches for its next physical address, per Urban Milwaukee.