Milwaukee/ Crime & Emergencies

West Allis Man Arrested Two Years After Wife Found Dying at Bottom of Stairs

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
West Allis Man Arrested Two Years After Wife Found Dying at Bottom of Stairs2900 S. 95th St. — Approximate Residence Where Wife Found Dying
Google Street View

A West Allis man was taken into custody Tuesday morning and charged with first-degree intentional homicide more than two years after his wife was found dying at the bottom of their basement stairs. Benjamin A. Carpenter, 45, faces the charge in the October 2024 death of his wife, Erica A. Carpenter, who was 40 at the time, according to prosecutors.

Police were called to the home on Oct. 13, 2024, at approximately 10:38 p.m. for a welfare check, according to WISN. Officers arrived to find Benjamin Carpenter performing CPR on Erica at the bottom of the basement stairs, per prosecutors cited by FOX6 News Milwaukee, which reported that police found her bleeding from her head. She was pronounced dead at a hospital the next morning, Oct. 14, 2024, at approximately 5:14 a.m., the station's report states.

Conflicting Accounts of How She Fell

According to the criminal complaint, Carpenter told police his wife collapsed while the two were doing laundry in the basement, and that he slipped while carrying her upstairs, causing them both to fall. The same report notes he said he “slipped, and they both fell.” West Allis police and prosecutors, however, say the physical evidence told a different story.

Investigators said the medical examiner found unexplained opioids and a high amount of sleep aid in Erica's system, along with blunt-force trauma to her neck, the outlet's report notes. A deputy chief medical examiner said per FOX6 News Milwaukee that her death may have resulted from asphyxia combined with that blunt-force neck injury, though Erica Carpenter's final cause of death was ultimately listed as undetermined. Toxicology reports showed insomnia medication and hydrocodone in her system at the time of her death, according to the same report.

Searches, Texts, and a Hidden Affair

During the weekend of his wife's death, Carpenter's Google history included a search for whether pills could be crushed and taken in water, per the criminal complaint.

Deleted text messages reviewed by investigators revealed that Erica had questioned Benjamin about putting powder in her drinks, police said. Separately, police discovered Carpenter had been having an affair with another woman, and that he had planned to tell his wife about it before she died, according to police accounts relayed by FOX6 News Milwaukee. The criminal complaint also described questions put to Carpenter about his jiu-jitsu black belt and a choke submission move, the station reported. Prosecutors say Carpenter later collected life insurance and benefit funds honoring his late wife.

A 2025 Call to the Same Home

In 2025, police were called back to the same West Allis address for another domestic abuse situation, this time involving Carpenter and his girlfriend, who told officers he had tried strangling her, according to police. An arrest warrant was issued for Carpenter, and the West Allis Police Department said he was taken into custody Tuesday morning.

The case lands amid a broader statewide picture on domestic violence. End Domestic Abuse Wisconsin's annual homicide report found that 82 domestic-violence-related deaths occurred statewide in 2025, and that men committed 86% of the state's domestic-violence homicides, with firearms used in 72% of the deaths, according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. When domestic-violence and family-violence deaths were combined, the newspaper reported, 101 people died in Wisconsin in 2025 — and the share of victims over age 50 rose from 26% to 31% over the past five years, per the same report.