
A group home worker in Mount Pleasant was allegedly beaten with a fire extinguisher and robbed of his iPhone after three people kicked in the home's front door, according to a criminal complaint. Three Racine residents now face burglary and robbery charges in connection with the Nov. 1 confrontation, which left the worker with visible injuries to his face, knee and back.
Police Called To A Dispute That Became A Burglary Report
According to a criminal complaint cited by Racine County Eye, Mount Pleasant police were sent to the group home at about 4:11 p.m. on Nov. 1 for what was initially reported as a dispute before it was called in as a burglary. The worker told officers that three people came to his workplace and attacked him, identifying them as Vantaya Johnson, Caroline Johnson and Vance Johnson, per the complaint.
The complaint says the three defendants entered the home by kicking in its front door, and the group home owner did not consent to the resulting damage. It does not state whether any residents were inside at the time, the outlet's report notes. Officers reportedly observed abrasions, open wounds and swelling on the worker's face, right knee and back, and he allowed police to photograph the injuries, though he declined an ambulance, per the complaint.
Fire Extinguisher, A Stolen Phone, And Dueling Accounts
The complaint alleges the attackers hit the worker in the face and right leg with a fire extinguisher, then took his iPhone and forced him to reveal its passcode. From there, the accounts diverge. Caroline Johnson told police she believed the worker had stolen money from a relative earlier that day, which he denied, the same report states.
Caroline Johnson also said she told the worker to open the door and forced it open when he opened it partway, and that he was the only person struck during the encounter, according to the complaint. She said the worker initiated the physical contact by swinging at Vance Johnson. She further told police the worker's phone fell during the fight and that Vantaya Johnson picked it up and took it when the group left, per the same account. Vantaya Johnson reportedly tried to transfer money off the phone but could not, and later threw the phone out of a car window, the complaint says.
Vance Johnson, for his part, told police the worker was beaten because he was a thief and had swung first. “I speak for me … I came to fight, that was it, that was all,” he said, according to the complaint.
Charges And Court Dates
Vance Johnson and Caroline Johnson are each charged as parties to a crime with burglary of a dwelling, a Class F felony carrying a maximum penalty of 12 years and six months in prison and a $25,000 fine, court records show. Both also face robbery with use of force, a Class E felony punishable by up to 15 years in prison and a $50,000 fine, along with misdemeanor battery, criminal damage to property and disorderly conduct.
Vantaya Johnson is charged in a separate case with the same five counts, court records indicate. A $25,000 arrest warrant was issued for her Nov. 9, and as of the report she had not yet made a court appearance and had no hearing scheduled. The three cases are numbered 2026CF001345, 2026CF001346 and 2026CF001350.
Vance Johnson made his initial appearance by video Nov. 3 before Court Commissioner Sally Hoelzel, who set a $7,500 cash bond; his bond was posted Nov. 9, and he was ordered to have no contact with the worker, the group home owner or the group home, and not to discuss the case with co-defendants, court records state. Caroline Johnson also appeared Nov. 3, with Hoelzel setting her bond at $3,500; it was signed Nov. 4 but had not been posted as of Nov. 10. Attorney Ashton Castro appeared for both Vance Johnson and Caroline Johnson at their initial appearances. Caroline Johnson's preliminary hearing is scheduled for 8:30 a.m. Nov. 11 in Racine County Circuit Court, with Vance Johnson's set for 8:30 a.m. Thursday, Nov. 12. Under Wisconsin state law, a preliminary hearing determines whether probable cause exists to believe a felony was committed by the defendant.
All three defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty. The case is one of several involving Mount Pleasant group homes in recent months; a separate complaint reported by The Journal Times alleged a second homeowner was victimized by a group-home resident, a claim an attorney for the home's operator disputed, while FOX6 reported that a Racine woman was separately charged with abusing a group-home resident.









