
Amanda Gibson checked into Music City Detox in February 2025 seeking help for alcohol and benzodiazepine addiction. Three days later, a nurse found the 45-year-old mother of four unresponsive in her bed. Now her son, a working paramedic, says state records show the staff tasked with watching over her falsified the very documents meant to prove she was being monitored.
Tyler Gibson has filed a wrongful-death lawsuit against Music City Detox and its parent company, Evoraa, according to Fox 17. He also filed a complaint with the Tennessee Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse Services, which led to a state investigation into what happened inside the facility during his mother's stay. Gibson, who says patient care matters deeply to him and that he treats every patient like family, told the station he hopes the lawsuit will help prevent similar deaths.
Facility intake records cited in the lawsuit say Gibson reported withdrawal symptoms, severe nausea, and fear that she might have a seizure when she arrived. Tyler Gibson has said his mother had diabetes and a history of blackouts. An autopsy later ruled her death natural, attributing it to a form of heart disease.
State Report Describes Falsified Monitoring Records
According to the state investigative report described by the station, two staff members responsible for monitoring Gibson falsified observation rounds, withdrawal assessments, and vital-sign entries in her medical record. The same report said surveillance video showed one of the nurses watching a movie and eating, then getting up several times without ever visiting patient rooms.
State records say Music City Detox terminated both staff members after the findings, and that each had previously received warnings for similar problems. Tennessee went on to issue the facility a licensure notice of noncompliance, citing “dereliction of operation” and “neglect.”
Music City Detox submitted a corrective action plan to the state afterward, which included additional staff competency reviews and monthly audits of camera footage. The facility told the station it is in good standing with the Tennessee Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse Services’ Office of Licensure and holds accreditation from The Joint Commission. The allegations in Tyler Gibson’s lawsuit have not been proven in court.
What Accreditation Does and Doesn't Guarantee
The Joint Commission said it evaluates healthcare organizations against hundreds of safety and quality standards, but it declined to comment specifically on this case, citing confidentiality. Facility accreditation does not guarantee that problems will never occur, the station's report notes.
Complaints and violations at rehabilitation centers are not routinely posted publicly, and records requests to obtain them can take weeks to be filled. People considering a treatment facility can check the state website to confirm whether it is licensed, and complaint records can be requested directly. Facilities can also be checked for accreditation through The Joint Commission or the Commission on Accreditation of Rehabilitation Facilities.
Tennessee's own licensing rules, filed with the Secretary of State's office, require the Department of Mental Health to investigate any report or suspicion of abuse, dereliction, or deficiency at a licensed facility. When an investigation or inspection turns up a violation, the rule requires a notice of noncompliance and a written plan of compliance laying out corrective actions and completion dates — the same process state records say played out at Music City Detox. The rules also call for at least one unannounced inspection of each licensed facility every year, and list a $500 civil penalty for a first Priority 1, or critical, offense, according to the Tennessee Department of Mental Health rules.
A Pattern Beyond Nashville
Gibson's case is not an isolated one in the addiction-treatment industry. In Kentucky, 56-year-old Mike Rison was found dead in his bed around 4 a.m. on July 17, 2025, at an Addiction Recovery Care treatment center he had entered less than two months earlier; a coroner's report attributed his death to cardiac arrest, according to the Lexington Herald-Leader. His brother filed a wrongful-death lawsuit in Pike Circuit Court that September, alleging no check-in logs were recorded for Rison in the seven days before his death and that no vital-sign checks or clinical assessment were performed after he received his largest dose of the medication Brixadi. A Herald-Leader and ProPublica investigation separately found that Addiction Recovery Care routinely staffed its residential facilities with employees who were not medically licensed or properly credentialed.
For Tyler Gibson, the fight now moves through the courts, where the claims against Music City Detox and Evoraa remain allegations rather than findings of fact. His complaint to state regulators has already produced a paper trail of warnings, terminations, and a corrective action plan — but whether it changes how closely detox patients are watched going forward is still an open question.









