Milwaukee/ Crime & Emergencies

No Charges for Green Bay Officers Who Killed Hunter Posey, DA Rules

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
No Charges for Green Bay Officers Who Killed Hunter Posey, DA RulesSource: Google Street View

Three Green Bay police officers will not face charges in the August shooting death of 27-year-old Hunter Posey, after Brown County District Attorney David Lasee determined their actions were reasonably appropriate and consistent with Wisconsin law on deadly force. Officers Noah Heuvelmans, Grace Bessey and Colton Moore opened fire on Posey after she allegedly raised a shotgun toward Heuvelmans during a welfare check that spiraled into a standoff on a residential cul-de-sac.

The shooting happened on August 21 in the 1700 block of Boland Road, according to WBAY, which reported that officers were called to the address just after 3 p.m. that day. As WFRV reported, officers had been dispatched to the same residence earlier in connection with an alleged custody dispute, and were sent back later that day for a welfare check after someone raised concerns for Posey's safety.

A 911 Call Requesting Deadly Force

Before officers arrived, Posey had allegedly called 911 herself, telling dispatchers she was armed and wanted police to kill her, per Lasee's report as cited by WLUK Fox 11. The station reports that Posey told the 911 operator she had a gun and would shoot people, and made reference to wanting officers to kill her. When responding officers arrived, they saw her walking around the cul-de-sac carrying a long gun, according to the same report.

Officers tried to evacuate nearby residents while attempting to talk Posey down, the station's report notes. Per the WFRV account, officers spent around three and a half minutes trying to engage her in conversation, repeatedly ordering her to drop the weapon. Posey put the gun down at one point before picking it back up, and the Fox 11 report adds that she sometimes dropped the gun but then disregarded commands to step away before retrieving it again, at one point pointing it around the area and at herself.

Officers Say They Feared for Heuvelmans's Life

The standoff ended when Posey reportedly pointed the gun at an officer, which the WFRV report states caused the three officers to open fire. According to Fox 11's account of Lasee's report, Posey raised the long gun toward Officer Heuvelmans, and Heuvelmans, Bessey and Moore said they feared she was about to shoot him. The officers also told investigators they believed they could not deescalate or disengage given Posey's conduct and the risk she posed to people nearby, per the same report.

Posey fell to the ground after the three officers fired their weapons, and officers then rendered aid to her before she was taken to a hospital, where she was pronounced deceased, the WFRV report states. An autopsy found that she died of three gunshot wounds to her torso, according to Fox 11's reporting on the district attorney's findings.

Gun Found Unloaded, DA Addresses Officers' Knowledge

In a detail that has drawn scrutiny to the case, Posey's double-barrel shotgun was determined to be unloaded after her death. Lasee wrote that there was no information suggesting officers knew the firearm was unloaded or that Posey posed no significant risk to herself or others, according to Fox 11's account of the report. Testing also showed Posey had a significant amount of alcohol in her system, along with other substances, the outlet reported.

The investigation included body-worn camera video showing police interacting with Posey before the shooting, which was released as part of the case record, per Fox 11. The Wisconsin Department of Justice had turned its findings over to the Brown County District Attorney's Office for a determination on whether criminal charges were warranted, WBAY reported following the shooting in September. Lasee's ruling concludes that review, finding that the actions officers took in the fatal shooting were reasonably appropriate and followed the legal principles surrounding the use of deadly force, according to WFRV's coverage of the announcement.

A Similar Outcome in Superior

The decision echoes a separate case in Superior, where Douglas County District Attorney Mark Fruehauf announced he would not pursue charges against Officer Ibrahim Carson in the fatal shooting of David Menton, according to the Duluth News Tribune. Fruehauf concluded that Carson was lawfully entitled to use deadly force to defend himself in that incident, which occurred outside Northern Aire Apartments on the night of April 7, the paper reported. A Superior Police Department use-of-force review separately and unanimously determined that Carson's actions were consistent with department policy, according to the same report.

The circumstances in Superior differed from the Green Bay case, but both decisions followed the same basic path: an outside law enforcement review, followed by a district attorney's determination that officers lawfully used deadly force. In Green Bay, that process stretched from the August 21 shooting to Lasee's announcement, closing out a case that began with a call for help and ended with officers firing on the person they had been sent to check on.