Milwaukee/ Politics & Govt

Oshkosh Middle School Bids Land $18.8M Under Budget, District Still Waits on Final Costs

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Oshkosh Middle School Bids Land $18.8M Under Budget, District Still Waits on Final CostsSource: Google Street View

Oshkosh School District budgeted $88 million for its new west-side middle school, and the lowest construction bid that came back was $69.2 million — a gap of $18.8 million. District officials are calling it good news, but they are also cautioning that it is far too early to say what the project will actually cost when all is said and done.

The figure comes from bids reported by WLUK, which described the number as coming in, in the station's words, “believe it or not,” $18.8 million under budget. The middle school is the single largest project inside Oshkosh's $197.8 million facilities referendum, which voters approved in 2025, according to the same report.

Superintendent Bryan Davis said the competitive bids put the district in a stronger position heading into construction. “To put us in better shape to be able to finish the projects,” Davis said, per the station's report. He added that the total project currently appears to be under budget, though he was careful to temper expectations about what that means long term.

Why the Final Price Tag Is Still a Mystery

Davis said the district will not have final figures for about two years, meaning the $18.8 million gap reported this week is a snapshot from the bidding stage, not a closing number. That timeline matters given the district's own recent history with construction costs swinging the other direction.

On February 11, 2022, the district reported that its Vel Phillips Middle School project was running about $4.6 million over budget after the lowest accepted contractor bid came in 9% above projections, according to a statement from the Oshkosh Area School District. The Northwestern separately reported that the lowest bid for that same school came in at nearly $50.7 million, also describing it as roughly $4.6 million over budget. That same cycle, the district said a second round of secure-entrance bidding drew only one contractor, whose bid ran more than double the anticipated amount, forcing the district to redirect $4 million originally set aside for those entrance upgrades toward the Vel Phillips project instead.

The Northwestern reported at the time that Oshkosh Finance Director Russ Van Gompel said rising construction costs were affecting some of the city's major plans. That earlier referendum, approved by voters in November 2020, totaled $107 million — less than half the size of the 2025 plan now funding the west-side middle school.

What the New School Will Look Like

The planned middle school is designed to combine South Park Middle School and Perry Tipler Middle School into a single building, according to a neighborhood update posted by the district. It would serve up to 680 students across grades 6 through 8 and include a three-court gymnasium, art and music studios, technology labs, and locker rooms with a weight room and fitness studio, per WLUK's report. The school would draw in students from South Park Middle School along with roughly 75% of Perry Tipler Middle School's current enrollment.

On the site itself, accounts differ. WLUK described the location as the former Shapiro STEM Academy site on West 18th Avenue, while the district's own neighborhood update described it as the current Shapiro Elementary site. The new school is scheduled to open for the 2028-29 school year.

A Name Tied to Local History

The property carries some local history of its own — the district's update noted that the land once held three stone quarries dating back to the 19th century, and it sits near a local landmark known as Quarry Park. That backdrop has fed into the naming process, with three finalists under consideration: Lewis Hine Middle School, Paul Poberezny Middle School, and Quarry Park Middle School.

Lewis Hine was an influential Oshkosh-born sociologist and photographer who lived from 1874 to 1940. Paul Poberezny, who lived from 1921 to 2013, founded the Experimental Aircraft Association. The Oshkosh school board is scheduled to select the final name on December 2.

Why the District Says It Can't Just Pocket the Savings

Under the referendum's terms, the district is authorized to levy up to $197.8 million in new taxes, but it has not collected the full authorized amount and cannot use referendum funds for anything outside the projects defined in the referendum's scope. The district's own tax-impact page states that the $197.8 million referendum would result in no increase to the school debt levy, because debt from previous projects is being paid off at the same time.

That structure means referendum spending cannot exceed $197.8 million overall, and the district says it will not levy funds it does not need if project costs come in under the authorized amount. Davis said any savings would instead go toward making sure the referendum's other projects include everything that was originally requested.

Those other projects include a performing arts venue at Oshkosh North High School and renovations to several elementary and middle schools, part of the district's broader push to consolidate from 20 schools down to 15 amid declining enrollment locally and statewide. WLUK reported the Oshkosh North venue as a performing arts center projected to cost about $5 million, while the district's own tax-impact page lists $22.1 million to build an Oshkosh North High School auditorium — a discrepancy the available records do not explain.

Michael Ford said school administrators are the ones responsible for carrying the projects forward from here, according to the station's report. For now, the $18.8 million gap stands as an early, promising number in a referendum that residents won't see fully priced out for roughly two more years.