
Ursuline College's athletic teams in Pepper Pike are staying put in their conference for at least one more year, after the Catholic women's college settled a lawsuit against the Great Midwest Athletic Conference over its membership status. The deal resolves a legal fight that began after Ursuline merged with Gannon University in 2025.
According to Crain's Cleveland, Ursuline has secured another year in the GMAC as part of the agreement.
The legal dispute traces back to the merger that made Ursuline College part of Gannon University. The Pepper Pike campus became part of Gannon in 2025, a transition that, per Crain's Cleveland, triggered concerns from the conference about whether Ursuline still met the GMAC's autonomy requirements for membership.
How the Conference Fight Started
The GMAC's leadership determined that Ursuline no longer qualified as an independent member once it became a Gannon campus. As reported by Inside Higher Ed, the conference's decision to expel Ursuline was set to take effect for the 2027–28 season. The same report noted the GMAC had granted Ursuline an exemption allowing its teams to keep competing against conference opponents during the 2026–27 academic year while the dispute played out.
Ursuline and Gannon responded by suing the GMAC, arguing the expulsion decision violated the conference's own bylaws as well as federal legislation governing discrimination in college athletics, Inside Higher Ed reported. The lawsuit specifically claimed the GMAC's move would disproportionately restrict athletic participation opportunities for women student-athletes at Ursuline, raising a Title IX argument at the heart of the case.
What Gannon Says About Ursuline Athletics
Gannon University's own website, describing the merger, states that Ursuline's teams would continue competing in the conference through the 2026–2027 academic year, matching the exemption period cited in the lawsuit coverage. Gannon's site also notes that Ursuline continues to retain a separate NCAA Division II athletics program, distinct from Gannon's own athletic department.
The sports-realignment outlet Sports Enthusiasts reported in July that the University of Indianapolis had been announced as a GMAC member beginning with the 2027–28 academic year, with the report characterizing that move as presumably intended to replace Ursuline's conference slot. That characterization was framed as an assumption in the original report, not a confirmed GMAC decision.
A Precedent From Pennsylvania
Mergers scrambling athletic conference membership aren't unique to Ursuline and Gannon. Inside Higher Ed noted that when six Pennsylvania state-system colleges consolidated into two universities in 2021, the NCAA and the Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference allowed all six teams to retain their independence and keep competing against each other within the same conference, avoiding the kind of expulsion fight that unfolded between Ursuline and the GMAC.
With the lawsuit now settled, Ursuline's athletes get a reprieve from the uncertainty that has hung over the program since the merger closed. The exact terms of the settlement beyond the extended conference membership have not been disclosed, and it remains unclear which conference, if any, Ursuline might eventually join once its time in the GMAC comes to an end.









