
More than two months after a crash near 51st Avenue and Bell Road left her with a severe traumatic brain injury, 16-year-old Phoenix resident Brionna Guggenberger is awake and largely breathing without a ventilator. Her family says the next stage of recovery is uncertain: doctors have recommended intensive inpatient rehabilitation, but the family's initial insurance request was denied.
The crash happened in September, when the car Brionna was riding in was involved in a three-vehicle collision near the intersection, according to 12News. Her older sister, Mikaela Guggenberger, was also in the vehicle and suffered a broken arm. First responders used rescue equipment to free Brionna from the wreckage before she was taken to the hospital with a severe traumatic brain injury and multiple facial fractures.
An Arizona’s Family report published in early September described a multi-car crash in the same stretch of northwest Phoenix. Four people, including two teenagers, were hospitalized; one person was pulled from the wreckage, and a 16-year-old girl was taken to the hospital in critical condition. A man, a woman and a 17-year-old were listed in stable condition, the station reported. Phoenix police were investigating and had not determined the cause, according to Arizona’s Family.
Emergency Surgery and a Father's Worst Fear
Scott Guggenberger said doctors warned him that his daughter might not survive. Brionna underwent emergency surgery to remove part of her skull and relieve pressure on her brain, followed by procedures to repair facial fractures and replace the removed section of skull. “It was every parent's worst nightmare,” Scott said.
Brionna has a tracheostomy and has opened her eyes and moved, her father said. Doctors have not determined whether she responds consistently to commands, and her family has been told her recovery could take months or longer. Scott said the eventual extent of her neurological recovery remains unknown.
Insurance Denial Stalls the Next Step
Doctors recommended intensive inpatient rehabilitation, including physical and speech therapy, but the family's initial insurance request for coverage was denied. The Guggenbergers are awaiting a decision on an appeal filed after additional neurological testing, according to the family's account relayed to 12News.
Arizona’s only acute inpatient rehabilitation facility dedicated exclusively to pediatric and adolescent care is the Frances H. McClelland Rehabilitation Program, run by Phoenix Children's. The program serves children ages 2 to 18 who are medically stable and able to participate in at least three hours of therapy five days a week. Patients typically receive 15 hours a week of physical, occupational and speech therapy combined.
A Dangerous Intersection's History
Crash records and past reporting point to a wider safety concern at the intersection, though they do not establish what caused Brionna’s crash. Between 2019 and 2023, the Arizona Department of Transportation recorded 192 crashes at 51st Avenue and Bell Road, 61 involving injuries, according to Arizona’s Family. In December 2024, a separate collision at the intersection involving a sedan and an SUV that slid into a school bus killed 17-year-old Beyonce Vasquez. The bus had no children aboard; Vasquez died at the hospital after being taken there in extremely critical condition, according to the Phoenix Police Department.
What State and City Records Show
Arizona’s designated trauma centers must be able to resuscitate, stabilize and transfer pediatric patients, according to the Arizona Department of Health Services. That statewide requirement concerns emergency care and transfer; it does not determine an individual patient’s eligibility for rehabilitation. The Phoenix Children’s program described above sets its own medical-stability and therapy-participation criteria. The City of Phoenix’s Road Safety Action Plan sets a citywide goal of reducing fatal and serious injuries on city streets. Its 2024 annual report says the city completed 102 identified safety projects from September 2022 through December 2024. Those citywide records do not establish what caused the Bell Road crash or whether any of the projects were at 51st Avenue and Bell Road, according to the city plan and annual report.
Family Leans on Routine and Support
Mikaela visits Brionna daily with her baby, the family told 12News. Before the crash, Brionna enjoyed football, movies, pizza, shopping and trips to California beaches.
The family has set up a GoFundMe for Brionna’s medical expenses and recovery, which has raised approximately $14,000 so far. Scott said donations and messages of support have helped the family, which plans to stay with Brionna throughout her recovery.









