
Organizers behind Plymouth's annual National Day of Mourning say the town has broken a 28-year-old legal settlement just days before this year's gathering, prompting an emergency court filing less than two weeks before Thanksgiving. The United American Indians of New England says its lawyers filed an emergency motion for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction against the town of Plymouth on Monday, alleging officials are attempting to tear up the 1998 agreement that has governed the annual observance for nearly three decades.
According to United American Indians of New England, the emergency motion was filed in Plymouth District Court on November 16. The organization, widely known as UAINE, says the filing accuses Plymouth of trying to break the settlement reached in October 1998, which recognizes the group's right to demonstrate on Cole's Hill and march through Plymouth on the National Day of Mourning without needing a permit, according to the settlement text UAINE has published online. That same settlement states that Plymouth officials will work with UAINE so that preparatory activities for the noon assembly on Cole's Hill are facilitated, and it designated the town manager as a standing liaison with UAINE for the observance in 1998 and in future years.
Per reporting from Struggle-La Lucha, which published UAINE's account of the dispute, the Plymouth Select Board voted on November 10 to cease compliance with the 1998 settlement agreement, ending the town's decades-long practice of helping facilitate opening speeches on Cole's Hill. The same account states that Plymouth is now refusing to provide UAINE a stage, is demanding requirements not included in the original 1998 agreement, and has repeatedly tried to insist that marchers be placed in a less noticeable, far corner of the park — even though UAINE holds the right under the 1998 agreement to choose its own march route.
A Settlement Born From a Violent 1997 March
The dispute traces back to the 1997 National Day of Mourning, when, according to UAINE's account carried by Struggle-La Lucha, more than 100 local, county, and state police kettled the peaceful march, arrested 25 participants, injured multiple people including elders, and used pepper spray on numerous people, including some who were already handcuffed. WBUR has reported that the 1998 agreement came a year after that clash, when participants attempting to march from Cole's Hill to downtown collided with police.
UAINE agreed in 1998 to drop a civil rights suit against Plymouth as part of the deal, while the town agreed that UAINE could rally and march every Thanksgiving without impediment or red tape, and agreed to provide supports including a stage. The settlement's financial terms are described differently across sources: the UAINE-hosted settlement text states that Plymouth paid $100,000 to the Metacom Education Fund, $20,000 to the ACLU for legal fees for the so-called Plymouth 25 defendants, and $15,000 for two plaques, while WBUR's reporting states the town paid $120,000 to the ACLU and $15,000 for the plaques. UAINE's charges from the 1997 arrests were dropped under the 1998 deal, and the organization says it has sought to comply with its end of the bargain for 28 years.
This Is Not the First Fight Over the Deal
The MetroWest Daily News reported that UAINE sued Plymouth in November 2025 over new insurance requirements the town had imposed, and that a hearing was held on November 25, two days before that year's observance. After the 2025 hearing, Plymouth and UAINE reached an agreement for the town to provide a stage and not require permits.
That standoff was resolved through an agreement allowing the 2025 event to proceed, with the town providing the stage and waiving permit requirements while UAINE agreed not to hold Plymouth liable for use of the stage, per WBUR's reporting. The Plymouth Independent reported that both sides agreed, following a 2025 Superior Court hearing, to meet before February 1 to negotiate terms governing future events. Whatever came of those talks, UAINE now says the town has moved again to unwind the arrangement entirely.
Organizers Push Back Ahead of the 57th Observance
Mahtowin Munro, a co-leader of UAINE, said the organization would oppose Plymouth's attempts to interfere with the National Day of Mourning, according to the account published by Struggle-La Lucha. Kisha James, a co-leader of UAINE and a member of the Aquinnah Wampanoag, said Plymouth prioritizes its “America's Hometown” fantasy over free speech and over its obligations to UAINE, per the same report.
Jean-Luc Pierite, president of the board of directors of the North American Indian Center of Boston — described as Massachusetts' oldest urban Indian center and the commonwealth's designated liaison for residents who are members of the Penobscot, Passamaquoddy, Mi'kmaq, and Maliseet nations — said Indigenous peoples' rights must be protected from abridgment. The center's account notes that the 1997 police suppression directly impacted its own membership and constituents at the time. UAINE has asked supporters to demand that Plymouth honor the 1998 agreement by contacting the Plymouth Select Board directly.
Participants plan to gather for the 57th National Day of Mourning on Cole's Hill in Plymouth at noon on November 26, continuing a tradition UAINE says has been held every Thanksgiving since 1970. UAINE has said this year's observance will be livestreamed from Plymouth. The available evidence does not establish how a court has ruled on UAINE's newly filed emergency motion, nor does it independently confirm the town's reasoning for the Select Board's reported November 10 vote.









