
Utah County prosecutors say they won't hand over most of the records behind Utah Valley University's after-action report on the Charlie Kirk shooting to Tyler Robinson's defense team, calling the request a “fishing expedition” in a new court filing. The response, filed in 4th District Court on Thursday, pushes back on 60 paragraphs of document demands his attorneys submitted last month tied to the university's 158-page review.
According to KSL.com, prosecutors argue most of what the defense wants simply isn't theirs to give because it is “not in the possession or control of a member of the prosecution team.” The report's authors, described by prosecutors as the “Project Team,” were contracted directly by Utah Valley University to assess event security and preparedness rather than to investigate the criminal case, and the team never reported to or contracted with any police department or the Utah County Attorney's Office.
Prosecutors told the court the Project Team has no tie to the prosecution and has not shared its underlying materials with either police or prosecutors, nor does it have any duty to do so. “In short, the Project Team has no tie to the prosecution,” the filing states, framing the defense's request as “nothing more than a fishing expedition” built on the mere possibility that the records might contain something relevant.
What the Defense Wanted
Robinson's attorneys filed their sweeping request on Oct. 6, asking for materials referenced throughout the After-Action Report, which Utah Valley University commissioned after the shooting to examine its planning, preparedness, decision-making, operational response and post-incident actions. The report itself, running 158 pages, was released in September.
The defense requests reportedly included Project Team interviews, the team's attempts to contact Turning Point USA members, communications between UVU's police chief and senior Turning Point USA staff, and UVU police rosters and time sheets covering Sept. 10 and 11, 2025 — the days surrounding the shooting. Prosecutors countered that the requested witness statements are not directly related to the murder case and said the materials instead concern an assessment of the event and recommendations for strengthening future security, preparedness, response capabilities and organizational resilience — not evidence bearing on Robinson's guilt or innocence.
What Has Already Been Turned Over
Prosecutors emphasized in the filing that they have already disclosed police reports, dozens of witness statements and witness video evidence to the defense. They maintain the additional Project Team materials are not mandatory disclosures because they aren't directly related to the case. Utah Valley University, for its part, declined to provide most of what the defense requested, though UVU administrators indicated they will share some of the requested materials with Robinson's attorneys.
Under Utah Rule of Criminal Procedure 16, prosecution disclosures must be made as soon as practicable after an information is filed, with evidence the prosecutor relied on to bring charges due within five days of a defense discovery request, according to Utah Courts. That rule doesn't by itself settle whether the disputed Project Team materials fall under its requirements, and the filing does not indicate whether a judge has yet ruled on the dispute.
What the UVU Report Found
The university's independent review, detailed by The Salt Lake Tribune, found that UVU staff had suggested moving Kirk's Sept. 10, 2025, event to a more secure location, but Turning Point USA insisted on holding it in the open campus courtyard. The review also found that students and employees did not receive a first alert until 19 minutes after the shooting, and that later messages contained contradictory and inaccurate information.
The 158-page report stopped short of clearing the university of responsibility, concluding that UVU could have done more and should not have ceded its authority to Turning Point USA, the newspaper's reporting shows. It also noted that UVU police Chief Jeff Long had texted Kirk's private security adviser proposing a meeting on final safety measures before the event — a meeting that, according to the review, “did not occur.”
A Separate Fight Over the Security Plan
The discovery dispute is distinct from an earlier public-records fight over the event's security plan. FOX 13 requested a copy of that plan the day after Kirk was shot, but Utah Valley University denied the request, arguing security-measure documents are exempt from disclosure under the state's Government Records Access and Management Act. Utah's Government Records Office director ultimately ruled that the security plans were not public records and should not be released, saying his office lacked authority under open-records law to order their release.
Robinson is accused of shooting and killing Kirk during the campus event on Sept. 10, 2025, at Utah Valley University. He was charged with aggravated murder, bound over to stand trial on all counts in September, and faces a possible death sentence if convicted. His trial is currently scheduled to start in June 2028.









