
Quincy Public Schools is taking four elementary schools' broken heating and cooling systems to court. The school board authorized legal action over alleged HVAC defects at Iles, Rooney, Baldwin and Denman elementary schools, with the district accusing designers and contractors of failing to deliver systems that could keep classrooms livable through an Illinois winter or summer.
A resolution adopted Wednesday night authorizes the litigation, according to The Herald-Whig. As KHQA reports, Quincy Public Schools announced the legal action Thursday morning, with the board resolution authorizing complaints concerning HVAC systems at the four schools. District officials said the HVAC concerns may affect school operations, the educational environment, and taxpayers' investment in public education.
Compressors Failed in Subzero Cold and Summer Heat
The scale of the alleged mechanical failures is significant. The lawsuits reportedly claim that 26 compressors failed districtwide, causing what one filing described as frigidly cold temperatures in classrooms during winter months and exhaustingly hot conditions when the weather turned warm, per the Herald-Whig's reporting. The district has said compressors and communication boards failed amid subzero temperatures in January 2024, the same outlet reported.
More recent breakdowns have hit even closer to the current school year. Compressors failed at Baldwin and Denman at the start of this school year, leaving two pods at each school without air conditioning, according to the Herald-Whig's account. A separate, earlier report from Muddy River News put the district's tally of elementary-school HVAC compressor failures at 21 as of June 2025, with nine of those at Lincoln-Douglas Elementary — a different figure than the 26 cited in the newer filings, and it is not clear from available reporting whether the two counts cover the same schools or time period.
Who the District Is Accusing
According to WGEM, the reported complaints name different design and construction firms depending on the school. Klingner & Associates and Waterkotte Construction are named in connection with Iles; Architechnics and Maas Construction are named as defendants in the Rooney and Baldwin complaints; and Poepping, Stone, Bach & Associates along with Maas Construction are tied to the Denman matter, the station reported. The four lawsuits reportedly claim breach of contract, negligent misrepresentation, negligence, breach of implied warranty of workmanship, and breach of express warranty, per the Herald-Whig.
The district is reportedly seeking damages to correct or replace the defective HVAC systems and ensure adequate heating and cooling in classrooms, the Herald-Whig reported. A representative of Waterkotte Construction told WGEM the company had no knowledge of a lawsuit. The evidence available does not include responses from the other named firms.
District Points to Financial and Educational Stakes
Superintendent Dr. Larry Gray framed the board's decision as a matter of fiscal responsibility. Gray said the board has a responsibility to protect the district's financial interests and ensure that school facilities function as intended for students and staff, according to WGEM. He added that authorizing legal action reflects the board's commitment to addressing significant HVAC concerns and pursuing remedies for the Quincy community.
School officials have said they have limited ability to comment on specific allegations or ongoing proceedings because litigation is pending, and the identity of all legal-action targets was not fully clear in initial reporting. This marks the second HVAC-related legal push by Quincy Public Schools in under two years: the board authorized a separate lawsuit in June 2025 against Klingner and Associates and Maas Construction over alleged faulty HVAC work at Lincoln-Douglas Elementary, according to Muddy River News. That earlier complaint sought damages in excess of $50,000 per count, with the exact amount to be determined at trial, the outlet reported, and a copy of the Lincoln-Douglas complaint filed in Adams County shows the district sought damages to correct or replace the allegedly defective systems so the school could provide adequate classroom heating and cooling.









