
A for-sale sign now stands where developers once imagined a five-story hotel rising next to the Rusty Rainbow footbridge in Bywater. The decade-long project has collapsed after its backers defaulted on a $1.65 million mortgage tied to the half-acre lot, leaving the property's future in limbo.
According to NOLA.com, Home Bank sued developer David Fuselier and his partners over the defaulted loan and then bought back the property at a sheriff's sale. The bank hired broker Jeff Melancon of RE/MAX Advantage last month to list the site, which now carries a $1.79 million asking price. A photo accompanying the report, taken on November 12 by photographer Sophia Germer, shows the for-sale sign posted right beside the bridge that gave the project its unofficial name.
Melancon told the outlet he has fielded some calls about the property but cautioned that broader market conditions are working against a quick sale. He said interest rates, construction costs and economic uncertainty are chilling demand for new construction, adding that a lot of factors are keeping people on the sidelines right now.
A Project a Decade in the Making
Fuselier has worked to complete the project for ten years, with the Crescent Hotel concept originating in the late 2010s. He has said he's spent considerable time and money trying to get it built. The plans called for a five-story hybrid hotel with 88 bedrooms and 24 apartment-style units, plus a rooftop pool, on the vacant lot next to the bridge.
Hotel plans were originally filed before the city's 2019 height-limit change, when the New Orleans City Council approved a reduction in the Bywater riverfront height restriction from 75 feet down to 55 feet. Construction was then delayed by the pandemic. In 2023, Fuselier filed updated plans for a 75-foot hotel and argued the project should be grandfathered under the earlier, taller limit.
The Fight Over Four Feet
The city council ultimately determined the project was grandfathered under the former height restriction, but Fuselier and his partners went further, seeking a waiver to build to 79 feet — four feet above even that grandfathered allowance. Developers said the extra height was necessary for economic feasibility, and Fuselier has said the additional floor would have made the project financially viable.
The city council denied that request. The city planning commission had found the site had no special conditions that would justify a variance. Mimi Spieler, Fuselier's sister and a partner in the project, pushed back on the outcome, saying, “We didn't feel asking for four extra feet was too much.”
Not everyone in Bywater saw it that way. Neighbors opposing the project said they support development within existing zoning rules, but no more. Kristin Gisleson Palmer, executive director of the Preservation Resource Center, said developers should build according to the rules in effect — not seek exceptions. Bywater residents have also voiced broader concerns about outside investors, second-home owners and short-term rentals pricing out locals and changing the neighborhood's character, worries that predate this specific fight. Even the Bywater Neighborhood Association, which considers itself the more pro-development of the neighborhood's two resident groups, wasn't fully behind the height waiver.
A Scaled-Down Comeback Attempt
Fuselier isn't walking away. He's now negotiating with a new lender in hopes of buying the site back, though he has said there's no timeline yet for a reacquisition or redevelopment. His revised vision is considerably smaller than the original: a three-story building with an 8,000-square-foot reception venue and 15 hotel rooms, down from the earlier five-story, 88-bedroom design. A rendering of the updated concept shows the ground-floor event space topped by two floors of hotel rooms.
Fuselier said event venues are in high demand, and the new proposal reflects that pivot — a venue overlooking the Mississippi River that could accommodate wedding parties, paired with a small hotel rather than the original large-scale project. He said he's searching for an operator for both the venue and the hotel rooms, calling the 55-foot Bywater riverfront height restriction too restrictive and saying it had stymied projects.
A Tough Climate for New Hotels
Any buyer or redeveloper will be contending with a cooler hospitality market than the one that first inspired the Crescent Hotel concept. According to the Bureau of Governmental Research, average New Orleans hotel occupancy ran at 69% from 2015 through 2019 but has averaged just 60% from 2022 through 2025. That softer demand helps explain Melancon's read on the market and the broader hesitation among buyers eyeing new hotel construction citywide.
For now, the lot beside the Rusty Rainbow sits listed and empty, its fate tied to whether Fuselier can line up financing or whether another buyer steps in with different plans. The bridge that gave the project its nickname remains a neighborhood fixture even as the hotel meant to rise beside it remains, for the moment, just a sign and a price tag.









