
A Sacramento-area landscaper named Julio says federal immigration agents followed his truck into a grocery store parking lot while he was driving to a job with a longtime friend, then handcuffed him and held him in a vehicle for about 15 minutes before letting him go. His friend was taken into custody. Julio, who has lived in the United States for more than 25 years and has no criminal history, is now one of the accounts the ACLU of Northern California is examining as it tries to determine whether immigration stops in the region show signs of racial profiling.
The ACLU of Northern California is still in what it describes as the fact-gathering stage, according to CapRadio. The organization is interviewing people who were stopped by immigration agents to understand both the encounters themselves and the reasons agents gave for approaching them. Emilia Garcia, an investigator with the ACLU of Northern California, said the group is looking into whether agents appeared to know about specific people before stopping them or whether the stops seemed random, and she noted that agents have pulled over work trucks carrying construction or landscaping materials, trailers or racks.
Julio, who entered the country without inspection and did not have legal immigration status at the time of the stop, had applied for a U visa — a form of immigration relief available to some crime victims who cooperate with law enforcement. Giselle Garcia, a representative of the mutual aid and immigrant-rights group NorCal Resist, said agents never told Julio why they approached his truck, and the paperwork he later received instructing him to report to ICE for a check-in gave no reason for the encounter either. Julio told CapRadio the stop changed his daily life even as he kept working and caring for his family, saying he no longer feels as safe going out because he fears arrest and fears being separated from his children.
A Rising Tally of Dispatches and Detainments
NorCal Resist's rapid-response network helps the ACLU connect with people who have been arrested or detained, along with their families. The group said it had completed intakes for more than 140 detainments since October 6, according to Giselle Garcia, though that figure is an attributed intake count rather than an independently verified tally of all detentions in the region. Separately, the organization reported documenting at least 83 detainments since October 6 as of late October, up from an average of about 21 documented detainments a month before that date.
The pace of reported activity has been climbing for weeks. NorCal Resist recorded 138 dispatches during the week of October 31 alone, not counting that Saturday's activity, Garcia said. Earlier in October, the group told KALW it was logging between 20 and 50 dispatches a day and confirming detainment intakes almost daily, compared with a normal week of 10 to 20 dispatches in the past.
Giselle Garcia said many of the reported encounters happened during the morning commute, between 5:30 and 9 a.m., and that most people in the reports were men of color. In one earlier set of 73 people, she said two or three were women and the rest were men. NorCal Resist's rapid-response network flagged nearly 80 cases for possible racial profiling since October 25, Garcia said, and the organization sent those flagged cases to the ACLU of Northern California for review — though the ACLU has not independently verified all of them as instances of racial profiling.
Observers Track Abandoned Trucks and Missing Workers
NorCal Resist also operates what it calls Migra Watch observers, volunteers who locate vehicles left behind after reported immigration-agent encounters and alert families about possible detentions. Garcia described one case near Marysville in which an employer contacted the group after four workers failed to show up and did not know the workers' full names. Migra Watch observers later found a vehicle on the side of a highway, and Garcia said coffee cups and lunches inside suggested at least four people had been in it.
Garcia said many people contacted by NorCal Resist end up signing voluntary departure paperwork after being detained, and that some told the group they felt pressured by ICE officers to sign those documents. She said many had little or no prior contact with the immigration system and no criminal record, and that some lacked the funds to hire an attorney. In Julio's friend's case, Garcia said he later signed paperwork agreeing to leave the country. NorCal Resist confirms voluntary departures through volunteer attorneys who check filings in the federal immigration court system, and verifies detainees' names and birth dates through the detainee locator system.
What the Law Requires — and What DHS Says
UC Davis law professor Kevin Johnson, an immigration law expert, told CapRadio that immigration officers generally need reasonable suspicion of unlawful presence before making an investigative stop. He pointed to a 1975 Supreme Court ruling that apparent Mexican ancestry alone cannot justify a stop but may be weighed alongside other factors, with the Court holding that officers must consider the totality of the circumstances. Johnson said evidence in a potential Northern California case could include stop data, locations, Spanish surnames and the reasons officers give for approaching people, and that any such case would depend on the facts investigators are able to gather. He added that ICE officers appear to be engaging in practices in the greater Sacramento area similar to those seen in Southern California.
That comparison stems from a federal judge's preliminary injunction issued in October barring detentive stops based on racial stereotyping across seven Southern California counties — Riverside, San Bernardino, Orange, Los Angeles, San Luis Obispo, Santa Barbara and Ventura — according to the ACLU of Southern California. That order, which came after the ACLU and other groups sued over immigration raids and alleged stops based on perceived Latino identity and other characteristics, requires agents to weigh the totality of circumstances rather than rely solely on someone's apparent low-income or working-class status and Latino identity. The Trump administration has appealed the injunction, and CapRadio reports it applies only to Southern California, not the Sacramento region. The underlying Southern California lawsuit traces back to July 2025, when residents, workers and advocacy groups first sued the Department of Homeland Security, according to the same ACLU of Southern California press release.
Johnson said a separate Northern California lawsuit could lead to similar restrictions if investigators are able to document racial appearance, language or work attire as the basis for stops, though proving such a pattern would require establishing common threads across many cases. The Department of Homeland Security declined to discuss specific enforcement operations, citing security and officer-safety concerns, and did not elaborate on what constitutes reasonable suspicion when asked. A DHS spokesperson rejected the allegations outright, saying the department's law enforcement does not engage in racial profiling and that immigration enforcement targets people unlawfully in the country, not people based on skin color, race or ethnicity. The spokesperson said ICE officers use reasonable suspicion to investigate immigration status and probable cause to make arrests. Neither ICE nor DHS provided the enforcement data CapRadio had requested.
A Nearby Echo in Sonoma County
The uncertainty over patterns in the Sacramento region comes as nearby Sonoma County reported its own wave of activity. The North Bay Rapid Response Network said at least 12 people were detained across Sonoma County beginning around 6 a.m. Friday, though ICE officials had not confirmed those detentions as of publication, according to The Press Democrat. Separately, KRCB reported the same network had confirmed three arrests before 7 a.m. that morning — one in Sebastopol and two in Petaluma — a smaller, independently confirmed figure distinct from the broader reported total. Sonoma County activated Phase 1 of its emergency contingency plan for immigration enforcement impacts in response, per the Press Democrat's reporting.
For now, the central question — whether Northern California's enforcement activity reflects a pattern of racial profiling — remains open. The ACLU of Northern California continues speaking with stopped individuals and their families as it examines whether broader patterns exist, while NorCal Resist keeps logging dispatches, intakes and referrals from a dataset its own organizers describe as not a comprehensive record of every ICE arrest or operation in the region. For Julio, the outcome of that inquiry is secondary to a more immediate reality: a daily routine now shadowed by the fear of being stopped again.









