
Along the cliffs above Pipes Beach, Grandview Beach and Beacons Beach in Encinitas, rocks are still breaking free and chunks of earth keep sliding away, a visible reminder that Southern California's bluffs are never as solid as they look. With El Niño conditions raising the odds of a wetter winter, a San Diego State University geologist is warning that the same forces already chewing away at these slopes could trigger another collapse before the season is over.
Pat Abbott, the geologist, walked the unstable coastal slopes with FOX 5 San Diego reporter Megan Healy, who authored the report examining how a wetter winter could reshape the county's coastline. Abbott pointed to rocks scattered at the base of the cliffs weighing 2 to 2.5 tons, telling Healy that the fallen debris weighs about 4,500 pounds and could kill someone it struck. He said a cliff failure could occur this year, and he urged beachgoers to look up before settling in below the bluffs, watching for large cracks and unstable masses poised to fall.
Cracks, Clay and the Mechanics of a Collapse
Abbott walked through why these cliffs give way. Gravity constantly pulls at unstable material, he explained, while rainfall adds weight to slopes and weakens the rock foundations beneath them. Clay minerals embedded in the cliff material absorb water and soften the ground, and when water seeps into existing cracks, it can expand and act like a wedge, increasing the likelihood that a section will break away. Abbott compared the process to cascading dominoes, where each failure removes the support holding up what comes next.
Surrounding slopes already show cracks and shifting sections that point to the possibility of more failures to come, and Abbott noted that vegetation growing along the slopes suggests there is already significant moisture working through the ground. He said existing cracks could become especially concerning if rainfall increases, since both prolonged, slow rain and brief, intense downpours can harm slope stability. Among the hazards he flagged are large sections of an approximately 45-million-year-old rock formation, the same type of material involved in the 2019 Encinitas cliff collapse that killed three women sitting on the beach below, according to Healy's report.
What El Niño Does and Doesn't Guarantee
El Niño conditions are associated with an increased possibility of above-average rainfall, and Abbott said the forecast anticipates a high probability of more than the usual amount this winter. But he also cautioned that El Niño is a climate pattern that does not necessarily determine Southern California's winter rainfall outright — it mainly helps forecasters prepare by pointing to rainfall patterns observed in the past. The winter of 2023-24 offers a cautionary example: El Niño conditions that season were relatively weaker, yet repeated rainfall over several months still saturated the ground and contributed to slope instability, according to the report.
A forecast from the Climate Prediction Center indicates a greater-than-79% chance of strong-to-very-strong El Niño conditions through January to March 2027, though that material does not establish how much rain will actually fall locally this season.
When Sensors Caught a Collapse Coming
The risk Abbott describes isn't hypothetical. A four-year, Scripps Oceanography-led study found that in-ground sensors detected movement of cliffs hours to days before failure at every site they tracked — two collapses at Del Mar and three at San Elijo State Beach, according to Scripps Institution of Oceanography. The report states that roughly 70% of the California coast is made up of eroding coastal cliffs, underscoring how widespread this hazard is along the shoreline.
One of those tracked events happened on April 21, 2024, when an estimated 200 tons of cliff material fell onto the beach below in Del Mar after sensor readings had already signaled an imminent failure and coastal managers were notified, Scripps reported. Researchers had identified a crack just 0.1 inch wide but extending 30 feet across the cliff top days before that collapse, according to the San Diego Union-Tribune. Sensors detected movement before the five failures tracked in the Scripps-led study.
Still, scientists are not promising a fix. Researchers cautioned that the five documented collapses tracked in the Scripps-led study are too small a sample to make reliable prediction routine, the North Coast Current reported. Weekly laser surveys conducted by Scripps researchers have separately shown increased erosion and small landslides along San Diego County beaches and bluffs following recent rainfall, according to Fox 5 San Diego.
Grandview Beach's Repeated Closures
Encinitas has already seen what a single failure can mean for public access. The city said it was notified that part of the Grandview Beach bluff just north of the staircase collapsed on September 18, 2026, according to NBC San Diego. The staircase had only recently reopened after a nearly $1-million refurbishment project completed earlier in the year, and it closed again following the September collapse. Engineers raised concern that another bluff failure could happen within 300 feet to the north or south of the staircase, the station reported.
That site carries heavier history than most. A 2019 bluff collapse at Grandview Beach killed three people, and two others were injured, according to the Washington Post. California State Parks has advised beach visitors to time their trips for low tide, when more sand separates the cliffs from the waves, and to keep a safe distance from the bluffs.
A Natural Process With Real Danger Attached
Abbott framed the erosion in broader terms as well. He described cliff collapse as a natural beach replenishment system, noting that collapsing cliffs can restock beach sand and sediment, while high tides and wave action break apart cliff material that also feeds the shoreline. Waves erode cliff bases over time, while rainfall and groundwater act as the triggers that can push an already unstable cliff toward failure, according to Scripps.
That natural cycle offers little comfort to anyone sitting at the base of a bluff when it gives way. Beachgoers seated against cliffs may have little or no time to react once a collapse begins, which is why Abbott's warning centers on watching the rock above rather than the sand below — especially in a winter when the odds of heavier rain are already stacked against Southern California's crumbling coastline.









