
A challenger who ran one of the smallest campaign budgets in the race has unseated a 16-year Utah House veteran known for championing mental health and homelessness policy. In preliminary results out of House District 43, which covers parts of Sandy, Midvale and Cottonwood Heights, Democrat Ofa Matagi was sitting at nearly 56% of the vote to Republican incumbent Steve Eliason's 44%, a lead of almost 12 percentage points, according to Utah News Dispatch.
The district has been represented by Eliason since 2011, according to The Salt Lake Tribune, making his likely ouster one of the more striking individual results in a broader statewide shift. As of Nov. 5, Matagi had not formally declared victory because some votes remained to be counted, though her double-digit margin made a loss unlikely, according to Utah News Dispatch.
Matagi's win is one piece of a much larger picture. Utah House Democrats and unaffiliated candidates were on pace to pick up 15 seats from Republicans statewide, with 13 of those gains credited to Democratic candidates and two to unaffiliated contenders, per the same Utah News Dispatch report. That shift was on track to cost the Utah House its Republican supermajority for the first time in more than three decades, leaving the GOP with a simple majority of roughly 46 seats out of 75.
A Statewide Blue Shift, District By District
Other election-night tallies described an even steeper swing. According to Utah News Dispatch's separate election-night coverage, unofficial results as of that Wednesday morning showed Democrats leading to gain 15 seats and unaffiliated candidates two, with Republicans on track to lose 17 seats and fall to 44 of the chamber's 75 seats. Utah Public Radio, reporting the same night, said Republicans began the year holding 61 of those 75 seats and needed at least 50 to keep their supermajority intact.
The two outlets differ on just how long that supermajority has stood. Utah Public Radio described the possible loss as the first in 26 years, while Utah News Dispatch's election-night report said Utah hadn't seen a House chamber without a GOP supermajority since 1993. Both outlets agreed that all of these figures remain unofficial, with thousands of ballots still being processed statewide and close races still subject to change.
Political pundits attributed the broader blue wave to frustration with the Trump administration and to how Utah Republicans have handled redistricting, ballot initiatives, unions, data centers and development, according to the Utah News Dispatch report on Matagi's win. Among the Republicans trailing Democratic challengers elsewhere in the state were Jim Dunnigan, Clint Okerlund and Anthony Loubet, the outlet reported.
A Campaign Built On Grocery Bills And Unanswered Calls
Matagi, who is Tongan American and was born and raised in West Valley City before moving to Sandy in late 2024, ran what she described as a campaign with one of the smallest budgets in the race. By day, she works as an environmental partnerships manager for the University of Utah's Neighborhood Partners program, according to the Tribune's earlier profile of the race, and she also serves as executive director of the Utah Pacific Islander Health Coalition, which advocates to improve health disparities affecting Pacific Islanders.
Matagi said she respected Eliason’s work as a bridge builder and had no ill will toward him. She identified equitable, sustainable environmental work and affordable, accessible healthcare as priorities, including environmental efforts for west-side residents disproportionately affected by climate change. She also said his departure would not end legislative work on homelessness or mental health.
Eliason Reflects On 16 Years And What Comes Next
Eliason, senior director of behavioral health policy at the Huntsman Mental Health Institute, spent 16 years in the Legislature advocating on mental health and homelessness. On Nov. 5, he joined Salt Lake County Mayor Jenny Wilson at an Office of Homeless Services summit at Fort Douglas in Salt Lake City to discuss Utah’s response to mental health crises, as reported by Yahoo News.
At the summit, Wilson asked attendees to give Eliason a standing ovation in recognition of his work on homelessness, mental health and suicide prevention. She said he would continue to have influence and described him as a dear friend, according to Utah News Dispatch. Eliason said he probably would not return to the Capitol as a legislator next year and attributed his loss to the statewide political shift.
Eliason said he planned to find sponsors for two omnibus bills addressing homelessness and behavioral health, as well as another proposal using $200 million from Utah’s Meta settlement for youth mental health services, Utah News Dispatch reported Utah News Dispatch. He said he would continue advocating for those efforts as a citizen lobbyist.
A Homelessness Measure Signed Into Law
A separate example of Utah’s homelessness-related legislation is H.B. 421, titled Homelessness and Vulnerable Populations Amendments. The Utah Legislature’s record shows the governor signed it on March 13, 2024. Eliason served as substitute sponsor on several versions of the bill.
Notably, an analysis from Utah Politics found Matagi raised less than $2,000 over the course of the campaign, framing Eliason's defeat as a loss to a challenger operating on a shoestring budget. That same analysis found Democrats statewide ran a median of about 8 percentage points ahead of Kamala Harris's 2024 showing in 73 of 74 contested legislative races, with two-thirds of districts shifting between 12 and 22 percentage points toward Democrats compared with past results.









