
Families gathered at Highland Park Elementary this week to discuss a proposal to close Sanislo Elementary and merge its students into Highland Park for the 2027-2028 school year. It's the second time in two years that Sanislo families have faced this exact scenario, and many in the room made clear they weren't buying the district's reasoning this time either.
A Familiar Fight Returns to West Seattle
Shuldiner, who is leading Seattle Public Schools through his first year as superintendent, told the crowd that internal merger discussions began in September, after the district finalized its new teachers' contract, according to West Seattle Blog. The district evaluated more than 100 schools districtwide and narrowed the list to 10 merger candidates, per the outlet's reporting. Sanislo was initially considered for a pairing with Louisa Boren STEM K-8, but the district settled on Highland Park instead, partly because Highland Park is a K-5 school like Sanislo, while Boren serves K-8.
District officials cited building condition, enrollment levels, an abundance of single-grade classes, partial FTE staffing positions, and limits on special-education services as the rationale behind the proposed pairing. Seattle Public Schools has officially confirmed that 21 schools are being considered for potential mergers heading into the 2027-2028 school year, according to KUOW, which reported that Superintendent Shuldiner cited declining enrollment as a key driver. The Sanislo-Highland Park pairing also appears on a broader list reported by Axios.
Enrollment Numbers and a District in the Red
District monthly reports cited at the meeting put Sanislo's enrollment at 124 students and Highland Park's at 339, for a combined total of about 460 students, the outlet's reporting states. That's a shift from November 2024, when the two schools reported 153 and 306 students respectively.
The enrollment slide isn't isolated to these two buildings. Districtwide enrollment has fallen to just under 50,000 students, down from roughly 56,000 before the pandemic, according to The Chronicle. The district is also staring down an $87 million budget shortfall for the current school year, as reported by Axios. Shuldiner discussed the district's current financial realities with the crowd.
Promises on Jobs, Buildings and Class Size
Shuldiner told families that every employee at both schools would remain employed, with attrition elsewhere in the district creating available positions to absorb staff. He said the district is still developing staffing formulas for a combined school. Counseling support, he added, could be allocated through a formula amounting to roughly one full-time counselor.
On the question of what happens to Sanislo's building, Shuldiner said the district would not sell it while he remains superintendent, and that officials are discussing alternative uses with partners — suggesting it could become a satellite library or community center. Leadership during a transition would also be shared: Highland Park principal Mary McDaniel and Sanislo principal Erika Ayer would serve as co-principals for the merger's first year, with the more senior principal staying on afterward and the other placed elsewhere among the district's 106 schools. Shuldiner acknowledged that the long-term leadership selection process hasn't been fully worked out, though he said past practice could factor into that decision.
Parents Push Back on Rationale and Access
Several Sanislo parents weren't persuaded. One parent said this marks the second attempt to close Sanislo in two years and argued the area has repeatedly been underfunded, calling the district's rationale unconvincing. Another raised concerns that past district decisions, including transportation cuts in the 2010s, had already harmed Sanislo's enrollment numbers. A parent also said families were presented with only one option rather than multiple scenarios to weigh, and raised broader worries about attendance-zone boundaries and a shortage of dual-language programs across West Seattle.
A Highland Park parent raised a different concern: that absorbing Sanislo's students could require additional classrooms and more counseling resources than the district has accounted for. Shuldiner responded that he is trying to provide every child with the best possible education and that improved district conditions in future years could allow programming to be added back. He said the district believes it can successfully move Sanislo's students into Highland Park, and that the support plan includes a social worker and team dedicated to students and adults, though he acknowledged the transition itself could be traumatic for some families.
A Process Still Far From Finished
Shuldiner stressed that the merger process remains in its middle stage, with 11 more family meetings scheduled. He reiterated that the superintendent has no final decision-making power over the outcome. His plan is to send an initial official list of proposed merger schools to the School Board in a letter, followed by community meetings and official hearings in January and February 2027. The School Board would then decide whether to accept his recommendation. Seattle Public Schools has described the proposal as a merger rather than a closure, and has said it is currently in a listening-and-feedback phase with no decisions made, according to a district meeting notice shared by West Seattle Blog. District officials also told families that open enrollment would continue for at least one week after any final decision, with students from a closed school given priority placement.
This isn't the district's first attempt at this exact pairing. In 2024, Seattle Public Schools proposed closing as many as 21 schools before scaling the plan back to four, and former Superintendent Brent Jones ultimately abandoned it after widespread public opposition. Sanislo was included in that earlier round too.
Families with more questions have additional chances to weigh in. Seattle Public Schools' superintendent is scheduled to hold an online community-engagement meeting Tuesday evening, and an in-person West Seattle session is planned for December 15 at the Denny/Sealth campus on SW Thistle Street.









