
Nonchalance Eatery & Wine Bar has closed its doors in south Fort Myers, and the shutdown reportedly caught even the restaurant's own owners off guard. The comfort-food-and-wine spot, tucked into Plymouth Plaza off South Tamiami Trail, announced in a Facebook post on Nov. 12 that it had shut its doors that day.
According to The News-Press, the sudden closure surprised even the owners themselves, though the report does not detail why the business shut down or whether the closure is permanent beyond the Facebook announcement. The restaurant was co-owned by Sarah and Dan Keagins, per that same outlet's reporting — though an earlier profile from Gulfshore Business identified the pair who opened the eatery as Daniel Keagins and Sarah Moonien-Klink, a naming discrepancy that remains unresolved.
A Quirky Comfort-Food Gem in Plymouth Plaza
Nonchalance built its identity around scratch-made comfort food with a twist, paired with an extensive wine list. The News-Press previously described the concept in its own words: “We are a wine bar with comfort food and childhood favorites with a twist,” according to the News-Press profile of the restaurant, which also noted the menu featured more than 30 wines by the glass.
Gulfshore Business, which covered the restaurant's opening, offered a similar description, quoting the owners' pitch that the eatery was “fun and have comfort childhood favorites with an adult twist.” That outlet placed the eatery at 15200 S. Tamiami Trail, Unit 104, inside Plymouth Plaza, and reported seating for 34 guests — a figure that conflicts with the News-Press's earlier description of eight tables seating about 30 people. The discrepancy between the two seating counts has not been resolved.
Part of a Rough Year for Southwest Florida Restaurants
Nonchalance's closure adds to what has been a difficult year for dining in the region. A News-Press roundup from July reported that seven longtime Southwest Florida restaurants had closed in 2026, though the evidence does not indicate those closures shared a common cause with Nonchalance's shutdown.
For now, there is no indication of what comes next for the Plymouth Plaza space the restaurant once called home.









