
A former 3M employee has filed a proposed class action accusing the St. Paul-based manufacturing giant of illegally overcharging tobacco-using workers on their health coverage. The lawsuit, filed Monday in the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota, claims 3M tacked on roughly $30 more per month for employees who use tobacco without meeting federal requirements for such surcharges.
The employee, Kristina Luck, alleges in her complaint that 3M's wellness program failed to give tobacco-using workers a legitimate way to earn back that monthly surcharge unless they quit smoking, according to Bloomberg Law News. Luck also alleges that 3M failed to notify employees of their program rights in every document that mentioned the price difference between smokers and nonsmokers. The claims laid out in the complaint have not been established in court, and it is not yet known how 3M has responded or whether a judge has weighed in.
Part of a Fast-Growing Wave of Litigation
3M, headquartered in St. Paul, Minnesota, is now one of a growing list of major employers facing this type of suit. A former Honeywell International employee previously sued that company over claims it charged tobacco-using workers $1,000 a year in surcharges without satisfying legal wellness-program requirements, the same outlet reported. Mondelez Global LLC has also faced a proposed class action alleging it charged smokers $100 more per month in healthcare premiums.
The surge of cases is notable in scale. Tobacco-surcharge litigation has grown to more than 80 cases nationwide, with more than 30 filed in 2026 alone, according to Insurance Business. That rapid pace of filings has made tobacco surcharges one of the more active fronts in employee benefits litigation this year.
Mixed Outcomes for Employers So Far
Not every employer facing these claims has lost. A Minnesota federal judge dismissed a proposed class action in July alleging that a tobacco fee on Target workers' health plan violated nondiscrimination provisions in federal benefits law, per Law360. That ruling shows employers can prevail when the underlying wellness program meets federal standards.
Other companies have fared worse. In a case against Compass Group, Judge Stephen R. Bough ruled against the company on all claims, finding an ERISA violation tied to the company's failure to retroactively reimburse a $1,248-per-year tobacco penalty to employees who completed a cessation program, Insurance Business reported.
Federal Guidance Offers Limited Shelter
Federal agencies issued joint guidance in August addressing questions raised by the wave of class-action lawsuits challenging tobacco surcharges in group health plans, according to HR Dive. But that guidance is no guarantee against future litigation. An attorney quoted by the outlet said the guidance “provides some arguments in rebutting those claims, but does not offer safety from such claims going forward.”
For 3M, the new filing adds the company to a list of employers now navigating this legal landscape in real time. Whether Luck's allegations hold up will depend on how the specifics of 3M's wellness program and surcharge notices compare with the federal standards already tested in the Target and Compass Group cases.









