
A new Italian restaurant and bar called Jo-Seppe is headed to Paulsboro Plaza, and it's coming from a name familiar to grocery shoppers across the Delaware Valley: the Stellato family. Brothers Joe and Rick Stellato, who run Stellato's Market, have signed a deal for the former Osteria 545 and Nino's restaurant space at 545 West Broad Street, with plans to turn it into a full-service Italian restaurant and bar.
The news first broke when Joe and Rick announced Jo-Seppe in a Facebook teaser that racked up almost 3,000 reactions and more than 800 comments, according to 42 Freeway. Paulsboro Mayor John Giovannitti also announced that the restaurant was coming to town, and the outlet reports he has urged the Stellato brothers for years to bring a business to Paulsboro.
From Osteria 545 to Jo-Seppe
The space Jo-Seppe will occupy has a long run in Paulsboro's dining scene. Osteria 545 operated there for approximately five years before closing in December 2025, and the location before that was known as Nino's. Per the same account, Jo-Seppe will undergo significant renovations to the restaurant and kitchen, though it plans to retain the classic bar that has anchored the space.
The restaurant may also incorporate an additional building section for dining and private events, and there's talk of outdoor dining with a deck or patio and fire pits. Those outdoor plans are not finalized, however, and are likely to be developed in a second phase, with outdoor dining potentially added after the restaurant opens. There's no announced official start date for construction, and the report notes Jo-Seppe will also need an anticipated liquor license transfer before it can serve. The target opening is 2027.
A Grocery Family's Italian Roots
Jo-Seppe will plan to serve classic Italian dishes made with fresh ingredients, and it will operate as a separate restaurant business from Stellato's Market. The grocery stores themselves aren't going anywhere — Stellato's Market will remain open at its existing locations at 1110 Mantua Pike in Wenonah and 775 South Route 73 in West Berlin, according to the company's About page.
The market traces back to 1992, when Rick Stellato, then 21, borrowed his old boss's pickup truck and line of credit to start a small produce-delivery company serving local restaurants, the company says on its website. Joe later left his job on the docks as an inventory manager and high-low operator to join his brothers, completing what the company calls “The Stellato Boys.” Today, Stellato's Market specializes in fresh fruits and vegetables, deli meats, catering, and other grocery products, and also runs a wholesale operation delivering products to Delaware Valley restaurants, including sauces, marinara, chicken cutlets, and other Italian specialties.
Choco Tacos and Bigger Ambitions
42 Freeway's report suggests Jo-Seppe's larger commercial kitchen may provide additional production capacity for Stellato's Market products down the line, hinting at ambitions beyond just the restaurant itself for Joe and Rick. The brothers have also built buzz around smaller items at the market — Stellato's sells choco tacos made by Vineland-based Outlaw's Burger Bar and Creamery, and the market reportedly sold more than 500 of them in one weekend after Joe featured the treat in a TikTok video.
For Paulsboro, the arrival of Jo-Seppe fills a storefront that's sat dormant since Osteria 545's closure last December and answers years of outreach from Mayor Giovannitti to a local business family with deep roots in South Jersey's food scene. With construction timing still unannounced and a liquor license transfer still pending, there's no firm date yet for when diners can expect to walk through the doors — but the 2027 target gives Paulsboro something to look forward to.









