Boston/ Politics & Govt

Sunderland Board Rejects Dollar General After 18 Months of Fighting Over Route 116

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Sunderland Board Rejects Dollar General After 18 Months of Fighting Over Route 116Source: Google Street View

Sunderland’s Zoning Board of Appeals voted unanimously to deny a special permit for a proposed 9,100-square-foot Dollar General at the corner of Route 116 and Clark Mountain Road, ending more than a year and a half of public hearings over the project. The board’s draft decision found that the store’s adverse effects on the neighborhood and town would outweigh any benefits it might bring.

The vote, taken Wednesday, capped a review process that stretched across multiple continued hearings, according to the Greenfield Recorder. Among the board’s central objections was that the proposed design did not comply with the town’s driveway-separation requirements, with the only access point identified as a 21-foot-wide space squeezed between two parcels. ZBA member Stuart Beckley said his vote was “particularly based” on the proposal’s impact on traffic flow and safety.

Traffic Data Became a Flashpoint

Disputes over traffic numbers dogged the proposal for months. At a hearing in March, Michael Wulforst reported that the applicant’s traffic study projected no change in Route 116 traffic levels, with data collected between 7:45 and 8:45 a.m. and 4 to 5 p.m. on a Wednesday and Thursday. Tighe & Bond’s peer review later found that data consistent with Massachusetts Department of Transportation traffic counts, the Recorder reported.

Residents pushed back hard against those findings. According to the same report, residents said the applicant’s traffic data contradicted what they actually experienced driving Route 116, a disagreement that had surfaced earlier when, per the Daily Hampshire Gazette, residents in attendance at an earlier hearing voiced similar disagreement with the traffic study results. The proposed curb cut was also described as sitting 100 feet from Clark Mountain Road, short of the town’s 250-foot zoning requirement, though the developer argued that regulation did not apply to the lot and that MassDOT, not the town, had jurisdiction over curb cuts on state highways.

Driveway Dispute Heads to Land Court

Behind the zoning fight sits a separate legal dispute over whether the property is actually one lot or two. Michael Pill, the attorney representing developer Calito Development Group, filed a Land Court petition against Sunderland in October 2026 over the driveway-separation issue. Pill has argued that a 2014 Approval Not Required plan Michael D’Ortenzio believes effectively divides the property is invalid without registration at the registry of deeds.

D’Ortenzio said in September that lawyers on the case were weighing case law pointing in opposite directions. A judge handling the matter postponed a determination until the ZBA issued its finalized special-permit decision, which state law required by Dec. 2, 2026.

Board Cited Neighborhood Character, Lack of Need

The board’s draft decision went beyond traffic and access concerns. It found that the store’s location and full-access driveway would create vehicle conflicts the board considered unacceptable, and that the 9,100-square-foot building would be out of scale with the small-scale commercial uses nearby, stating the structure would dwarf other buildings in that part of town and elsewhere in Sunderland.

Sunderland’s bylaws require the ZBA to weigh eight categories of adverse and beneficial effects, and ZBA member Hollis Graves pointed to social, economic or community needs as one factor shaping his vote. The draft decision stated the board found no community need for a large retail store in Sunderland and that the proposal would not serve an economic or community need in town. It also noted that public comments opposed the store and that none supported it, with local business owners claiming the chain would draw customers away from their shops and hurt the local economy and community.

Developer’s Attorney Vows to Appeal

Pill told the Recorder he plans to appeal the ZBA’s denial. He argued the board had made up its mind long ago and was searching for every possible reason to deny the permit, and he characterized the hearing process itself as unfair. Pill also said the applicant had spent heavily addressing issues raised through multiple peer reviews.

Pill further argued that denying the permit would harm the interests of Sunderland residents, saying they would otherwise need to travel to Greenfield, Northampton or Hadley for a grocery store. ZBA Chair Steve Krol disputed the characterization of an unfair process, saying the board had provided a fair, open hearing: “I think we did. We strived to do that.”

A Familiar Fight for the Developer

Calito Development Group has run into similar resistance elsewhere in western Massachusetts. In South Deerfield, the town’s ZBA approved a special permit for a proposed Dollar General on Routes 5 and 10 subject to 28 conditions, a decision the developer later challenged in Land Court, according to Recorder reporting from 2021. In Southwick, the Planning Board voted 3-2 in favor of a Calito Dollar General permit, but the vote fell short of the required 4-1 supermajority; Calito subsequently filed two lawsuits seeking to overturn that outcome, per MassLive.

With the Sunderland permit now denied and an appeal promised, the Route 116 property’s fate remains tied up not just in zoning law but in the still-unresolved Land Court question over whether the parcel can even be treated as one buildable lot.