Nashville/ Crime & Emergencies

Tennessee Highway Patrol Skipped Or Botched Nearly 60% of Evidence Checks, Audit Finds

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
Tennessee Highway Patrol Skipped Or Botched Nearly 60% of Evidence Checks, Audit FindsSource: Compagnons / Unsplash

Guns, drugs, blood alcohol kits and seized vehicles sit in Tennessee Highway Patrol custody across the state, and a new state audit says the agency failed to properly check on much of that evidence for two straight years. Auditors evaluated 126 evidence reviews THP was required to perform between 2023 and 2025 and found that only 41% were done correctly, while the rest were either skipped entirely or carried out incorrectly.

According to the Tennessee Comptroller’s Office, auditors found that 40 of those required reviews were not performed at all, and another 34 were completed but done incorrectly, as reported by wbbjtv.com. State auditors found that 32% of required reviews were not performed and another 27% were performed but did not meet all the requirements laid out in THP’s evidence manual, per WKRN News 2. Tennessee Highway Patrol handles evidence ranging from narcotics and firearms to blood alcohol concentration kits and seized vehicles, and the agency requires regular reviews of that evidence under its own evidence manual.

Missing Paperwork and Unexplained Gaps

Of the flawed reviews, 24 lacked any proof that the reviewer had actually examined the related case files, the same report notes. Four additional reviews were missing required information altogether, including case numbers and the type of evidence involved, according to wvlt.tv.

Auditors determined that THP management failed to ensure staff performed the reviews properly, and WKRN News 2 reports that THP managers themselves disagreed over what the evidence manual’s review rules actually required. Managers also told auditors that time constraints made completing the reviews difficult. The audit noted that review requirements were spread across different sections of the evidence manual rather than consolidated into a dedicated section, the same account states.

Storage Lot Problems and Security Gaps

The audit also examined THP’s three vehicle storage lots and found security limitations at some of them, per WKRN News 2. Investigators found that staff did not properly track some evidence vehicles, failed to clear debris from storage lots, and in some cases parked trooper vehicles next to evidence vehicles. Auditors said they withheld certain security-risk details from the public report because of potential safety and security concerns, the station notes.

Some THP evidence custodians reported they had not received structured instruction or written guidance for certain responsibilities, including vehicle storage lot procedures, according to the same report. State auditors recommended that THP managers clarify staff responsibilities and increase oversight of the review process. Olidia Guevara said improper or unperformed reviews could reduce management’s ability to identify deficiencies in evidence handling or accountability, per WKRN News 2.

THP Response and Planned Fixes

THP management told auditors it concurred with the findings and is in the process of refining its evidence custodian processes and training, which includes updates to the evidence manual, the wbbjtv.com report states. Management also said district captains will verify that all evidence audits, inventories and required reviews are fully completed going forward. THP management told auditors that new facilities were being developed to improve lot security and provide dedicated storage separating evidence from trooper vehicles, per the audit.

Colonel Matt Perry told lawmakers that the audit’s findings and recommendations would help improve the agency, according to WKRN News 2. Perry said the department’s lowest layer of auditing was not being done appropriately, but he said the audit concerned the auditing process itself rather than any compromised or missing evidence, the station reports. THP is updating its evidence manual and policies to clarify how district captains and evidence custodians should complete reviews going forward.