Nashville/ Community & Society

Tennessee Lands Near Bottom of New Family-Friendly State Rankings, Safety Drags It Down

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Tennessee Lands Near Bottom of New Family-Friendly State Rankings, Safety Drags It DownSource: w_lemay / Wikimedia Commons

Tennessee just landed near the bottom of a fresh national ranking of the best states to raise a family, and the state's weakest showing came in an area that tends to matter most to parents: safety. The Volunteer State placed ninth-worst overall out of 50 states, earning just 44.49 points out of a possible 100 in the 2026 study.

The ranking comes from ConsumerAffairs, which analyzed every state across five categories: affordability, safety, education, healthcare and quality of life. According to the Tennessean, Tennessee ranked No. 15 in affordability, No. 46 in safety, No. 30 in education, No. 27 in healthcare and No. 25 in quality of life.

Safety Was the Biggest Drag on Tennessee's Score

Of the five categories, safety was by far Tennessee's weakest, landing the state at No. 46 nationally. The Tennessean's report notes that ConsumerAffairs considered the violent crime rate and property crime rate per 1,000 residents when calculating safety scores — the two metrics that pulled Tennessee's overall ranking down the most.

Healthcare also factored heavily into the rankings. Per the same report, ConsumerAffairs' healthcare scores included the number of pediatricians per 100,000 people, infant mortality rates, the percentage of uninsured children, and the percentage of families who struggled to pay for children's medical bills in the past year. Tennessee came in at No. 27 in that category.

A Separate Study Found a Similar Education Gap

Tennessee's No. 30 education ranking in this family study lines up with — but is not identical to — a separate ConsumerAffairs Best States for Public Education study, which placed Tennessee at No. 31, the Tennessean reports. The two figures measure different things, but both point to Tennessee trailing much of the country in classroom outcomes.

Geography played a visible role in the overall results. Seven of the 10 best states to raise a family are located in the Northeast, according to ConsumerAffairs. The Tennessean adds that of the 10 best states, only three were outside the Northeast, while six of the 10 worst states were in the West.

Who Topped the List, and Who Fell

Connecticut claimed the No. 1 spot overall in 2026, a jump from sixth place the year before, according to ConsumerAffairs. Massachusetts stood out as the only state to earn a No. 1 ranking in more than one category, topping both public education and healthcare, per the Tennessean. Alaska ranked dead last overall, falling into the bottom seven nationally for affordability, safety and education.

Year over year, the rankings shifted sharply for some states. California posted the largest improvement, climbing 13 spots to No. 31, while Wisconsin, Idaho, Indiana and Missouri each fell nine places compared with 2025, ConsumerAffairs reports.

The Cost of Living Adds Another Layer

Affordability remains one of Tennessee's stronger categories relative to its other scores, but the cost of simply getting by in the state is still steep for many households. A separate SmartAsset estimate reported by the Tennessean found that a single adult in Tennessee needed about $89,898 a year to live comfortably in 2026 — a figure that actually marked a 1.7% decrease from 2025. For a family of four, that required income rises to $197,267 annually. SmartAsset reached those numbers by applying the 50/30/20 budgeting rule to living-wage data from the MIT Living Wage Calculator, the Tennessean notes.

Other national studies have reached different conclusions about which states serve families best. WalletHub's own 2026 ranking, which evaluated states using 50 indicators across family fun, health and safety, education and child care, affordability, and socio-economics, named Massachusetts the best state overall and Minnesota a close second. The methodologies differ enough from ConsumerAffairs' approach that the two studies aren't directly comparable, but both point to the same handful of Northeastern and Midwestern states consistently rising to the top of family-friendliness rankings nationwide.