
Governor-elect Marsha Blackburn has picked Josh Smith, a former deputy director of the Federal Bureau of Prisons who once served five years in federal prison himself, to lead the Tennessee Department of Correction. The appointment comes just weeks after two botched execution attempts this year rattled the state's prison system and cost the previous commissioner his job.
A Pardoned Former Inmate Takes the Helm
Smith was named to the position by the Republican governor-elect, according to CBS News. He pleaded guilty in 1998 to conspiring to possess and distribute cocaine and marijuana, served a five-year sentence, and was later granted a full pardon by President Trump, according to an archived White House statement from January 2021. Blackburn said Smith brings “a distinctive combination of executive leadership, firsthand correctional experience, and an understanding of the challenges facing our prison system,” per CBS News.
Smith went on to become the first former federal prisoner to hold a senior position as deputy director of the Federal Bureau of Prisons, according to The Tennessean. In that role, he helped oversee roughly 155,000 inmates across more than 120 institutions nationwide. He abruptly resigned from the federal post in August, the station's report notes, without a stated reason. Smith also founded the Fourth Purpose Foundation, a nonprofit the Tennessean describes as focused on prison reform, rehabilitation and helping formerly incarcerated people return to society, and he served on Governor Bill Lee's Tennessee Criminal Justice Investment Task Force in 2019.
Taking Over After a String of Execution Failures
Smith will succeed interim Director Christopher Hansen, who stepped in after Frank Strada resigned as commissioner following the botched execution of death-row inmate Christa Pike, per the same account from CBS News. Pike, sentenced to death for the 1995 torture and murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, survived two rounds of typically lethal chemicals during her execution attempt, according to WKRN News 2. Her attorneys said the pentobarbital did not enter her bloodstream correctly, and a judge ordered the drug preserved as evidence.
It was the second failed execution attempt in Tennessee this year, according to Tennessee Lookout. Back in May, state officials halted the execution of Tony Carruthers after corrections staff spent more than an hour trying and failing to find a vein for a secondary IV, as reported by CNN. Governor Lee granted Carruthers a one-year reprieve as a result, and has since put all executions on hold for the remainder of 2026 while ordering a third-party investigation.
A Protocol Already Under Scrutiny
Lee ordered former U.S. Attorney Ed Stanton to lead an independent review of whether the Department of Correction followed its lethal-injection protocol and whether changes are needed, The Tennessean reports. Stanton has reviewed the state's execution procedures before: a December 2022 report he authored found that the department had failed to follow its lethal-injection protocol since it was introduced in 2018, including failing to properly test three drugs for endotoxins. Tennessee later finalized a new protocol in December 2024, switching from a three-drug cocktail to pentobarbital alone.
Blackburn, for her part, has called for the state to explore alternative execution methods, including the electric chair, according to WPLN News. Tennessee Lookout similarly reports that Blackburn wants electrocution via electric chair to become the primary method of carrying out the death penalty in the state.
Smith Lays Out His Priorities
Smith said the Tennessee correctional system is confronting serious strain, citing “staffing shortages, institutional safety, and the need to strengthen leadership,” per CBS News. Speaking to Tennessee Lookout, he said his focus would be on “institutional security, accountability, employee safety, effective community supervision, and preparing prisoners to become productive citizens.”
He added that he intends to take a measured approach before making changes. “I look forward to listening to employees, evaluating operations, and working with state leaders and public-safety partners,” Smith said, according to Tennessee Lookout. On social media, Blackburn wrote that Smith brings “a distinctive combination of executive leadership, firsthand correctional experience, and an understanding of the challenges facing our prison system,” in a post on X
.









