
The Tennessee Highway Patrol will pay $70,000 to settle a lawsuit filed by Stephanie Fair, a driver whose blood work later showed she was completely sober when a trooper arrested her for DUI. The trooper who pulled her over said he smelled alcohol, but Fair says that's impossible because she doesn't drink at all.
According to WSMV, the Tennessee State Board of Claims has approved the settlement, and a payout is expected within the next few weeks. Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, told the station she does not drink alcohol — “But on my life, I don't drink alcohol,” she said — and that the arrest left her more unsettled by the trooper than by the jail cell that followed. “I was more scared being with that cop alone than I actually was inside the jail,” Fair said.
Video obtained by WSMV4 Investigates reportedly shows Fair eating ice cream before her arrest, a detail that stands in contrast to the trooper's account that he detected the odor of alcohol on her. The station's reporting does not resolve how those two accounts fit together beyond noting that her later blood work came back showing no alcohol in her system.
A Pattern Involving the Same Trooper
Fair's case is not isolated. The station's report identifies Trooper James Zahn as having been accused of arresting nine sober drivers for DUI, a figure built from court records and lawsuits cited in the reporting. Among those alleging wrongful arrest is Jane Bondurant, a former U.S. attorney whom Zahn arrested as his eighth sober driver by that count, and Labreesha Batey, a NASA employee also suing the state over her arrest.
A Thompson Station man separately alleged in a lawsuit that Zahn arrested him for DUI while he was sober — an allegation that, if counted, would bring the trooper's total to nine sober drivers arrested. The same report notes that the Rutherford County Sheriff's Office and La Vergne police have also settled lawsuits brought by sober drivers who were arrested for DUI, suggesting the problem extends beyond a single agency or trooper.
Not the First Payout of Its Kind
Fair is described in the reporting as the second sober driver to sue the Tennessee Highway Patrol and reach a settlement. The first was Thomas Manis, who received $75,000 after state troopers arrested him for DUI in East Tennessee. A separate WSMV report on the case states Manis was arrested by THP troopers in Monroe County in 2023 and that his bloodwork later came back showing no alcohol and no drugs, with the $75,000 settlement confirmed by the Tennessee Board of Claims.
A separate WSMV investigation page states that a Rutherford County man was to receive $90,000 from the county after being wrongfully arrested for DUI, adding another figure to the running tally of payouts tied to questionable DUI stops in Middle Tennessee. The same investigation page notes that the Tennessee Highway Patrol has ordered 1,200 portable breath test devices for $510,000, a purchase the page frames within its ongoing coverage of these cases.
How Big Is the Underlying Problem?
Reports differ on how to characterize the scale of the issue across the state in 2024. NewsChannel 5 reported that 419 of nearly 17,000 blood samples submitted after Tennessee DUI arrests that year came back with zero alcohol or other intoxicants detected, describing that figure as roughly 2.5% of the samples tested, according to NewsChannel 5. NewsNation, meanwhile, described the same 419 figure differently, reporting that 419 people across Tennessee were arrested for driving under the influence in 2024 despite later blood tests showing no alcohol detected in their system, according to NewsNation. The two outlets don't appear to reconcile whether that number reflects blood samples or individual arrests.
Attorney Says Lawsuits Are the Only Path
Attorney Ben Raybin, cited in the WSMV reporting, said the state recognized that many such arrests were legally unsupportable and that juries could rule against it if the cases went to trial. Raybin also said that sober drivers' only option, once charges stemming from a bad arrest are dismissed, is to sue — Tennessee does not otherwise provide sober drivers a way to recoup the costs of fighting a DUI charge that is later dropped.
A Nashville criminal-history record search lists the disposition of Fair's DUI case as nolle prosequi, dated Nov. 5, 2024, with the case status listed as closed, according to the Nashville Criminal Court Case Search. The record excerpt does not establish any further detail about how or why the charge was resolved that way.









