
A Coffee County grand jury has indicted the former president of the parent-teacher organization at Bel-Aire Elementary School in Tullahoma, accusing her of misappropriating more than $57,000 in school funds over roughly two and a half years. Samantha Zimmerman was indicted in November 2026 following an investigation into the Bel-Aire Elementary PTO’s finances during her time leading the group.
According to FOX13 Memphis, the indictment includes one count of theft over $10,000, two counts of forgery and two counts of tampering with governmental records. The charges stem from an investigation by the Tennessee Comptroller’s Office, which attributed at least $57,522.62 in misappropriated school-organization funds to Zimmerman. Bel-Aire Elementary is part of the Tullahoma City School District in Coffee County, Tennessee.
Zimmerman served as PTO president from August 7, 2023, to January 29, 2026, and the alleged misappropriation is reported to have occurred during that same stretch, from August 2023 through January 2026. Tullahoma City School District officials reported financial discrepancies involving Zimmerman, which set the investigation in motion.
How Investigators Traced the Missing Money
Investigators attributed $31,820.49 in cash withdrawals from the PTO bank account to Zimmerman, plus $21,215.86 in personal purchases made with a PTO debit card. Those purchases reportedly included entertainment, household items, food and drinks, clothing, vehicle maintenance, and storage unit rentals. Investigators also said at least $4,486.27 in fundraiser and Venmo funds was misappropriated.
Among the more unusual findings, Zimmerman rented six storage units using PTO funds, and investigators determined five of the six were for her personal use. Per the same account, Zimmerman acknowledged making withdrawals unrelated to PTO operations and using the money for personal expenses.
A Shrinking Bank Balance and False Reports
Zimmerman reported the PTO’s bank balance at approximately $34,938 in August 2025, but bank records show the account actually contained less than $1,900 around that same time. The gap points to what investigators described as false annual financial reports Zimmerman submitted to school officials.
Beyond the confirmed misappropriation, investigators identified at least $77,307.96 in questionable PTO disbursements unsupported by verifiable financial records, including missing receipts, invoices and other documentation needed to verify the legitimacy of expenditures. That $77,307.96 figure was established as separate from the confirmed misappropriation total and does not represent additional proven stolen funds. The Comptroller’s Office reported that Zimmerman repaid $20,000, leaving $37,522.62 unrecovered.
Comptroller Warns of Oversight Gaps
Tennessee Comptroller Jason Mumpower said school support organizations must maintain accurate records and divide financial responsibilities properly among officers. He said allowing one person to control deposits, spending and bank reconciliations without oversight creates an opportunity for undetected fraud.
It’s a concern the Comptroller’s Office has flagged before. In a 2024 investigation involving the White House Heritage PTO, Mumpower said that inquiry revealed “a number of deficiencies related to oversight and accountability within the PTO,” according to the Tennessee Comptroller of the Treasury. A separate 2022 case involving the Kingston Elementary PTO drew a similar warning from the Tennessee Comptroller of the Treasury, which found the PTO had failed to provide adequate oversight and accountability of its funds.









