Memphis/ Crime & Emergencies

Two Memphis Caregivers Indicted After TennCare Fraud Probe Tied to UnitedHealthcare Tip

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Two Memphis Caregivers Indicted After TennCare Fraud Probe Tied to UnitedHealthcare TipSource: Thomas R Machnitzki / Wikimedia Commons

Two Memphis home caregivers are facing felony charges after state investigators say they billed TennCare for patient visits that either overlapped in ways that weren't physically possible or never happened at the claimed location at all. Tina Poindexter, 50, and Tyrone Clements, 49, were indicted by a Shelby County grand jury in September and booked into the Shelby County Jail, according to the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation.

The case traces back to April 2025, when special agents with the TBI's Medicaid Fraud Control Division received a fraud complaint from UnitedHealthcare alleging the two caregivers took part in a scheme to fraudulently bill TennCare, according to the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation. Investigators determined that from May 2022 through August 2024, Poindexter submitted claims for the concurrent care of two patients during overlapping time periods, the agency says — meaning her reported services could not have actually been provided simultaneously.

Timesheets Didn't Match Location Records, TBI Says

Clements' case centered on a mismatch between his reported work and his whereabouts. Investigators who examined timesheets he submitted found that records showed him clocking in and out several miles from the patient's residence while he reported providing care there, per the TBI. Special agents say the evidence developed in the case showed both caregivers received TennCare payments for services they were not entitled to bill, and that they fraudulently billed the program and collected thousands of dollars in payments they weren't entitled to.

The Shelby County grand jury's September indictments charged Poindexter with one count each of TennCare fraud and theft of property, both in the $10,000 to $60,000 range. Clements was charged with one count each of TennCare fraud and theft of property in the $2,500 to $10,000 range, the TBI reports. The agency notes those figures reflect the charged financial ranges rather than a final determination of how much money was actually obtained.

Bond Set, Court Date Pending

Both defendants were arrested and booked into the Shelby County Jail, with the TBI noting the arrests were assisted by the Shelby County Sheriff's Office and the Memphis Police Department's fugitive unit. The agency's release doesn't specify exact arrest dates or provide information about upcoming court appearances. Action News 5 reports that Poindexter and Clements have since been freed on $1,000 bonds and are due back in court December 2.

As with any indictment, the allegations against Poindexter and Clements remain accusations at this stage. The TBI's release states that a defendant is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt and convicted through due process of law.

Not the First TennCare Caregiver Case in Memphis

This isn't the only recent case of its kind out of Memphis. Earlier this year, the TBI announced the arrests of three former caregivers — Lakesha Albright, Erika Humphreys and Yosha Fletcher — who were accused of providing in-home care to the same physically disabled TennCare member from January 2022 through June 2024 while submitting fraudulent time records. A Shelby County grand jury indicted all three in January on one count each of TennCare fraud and theft of services, and the agency said Albright was apprehended January 21 while Humphreys and Fletcher were taken into custody two days later, with all three booked into the Shelby County Jail.

The newly announced case against Poindexter and Clements was first reported by FOX13 Memphis, which detailed the charges stemming from the TBI's investigation into the billing records. Both the current case and January's prior arrests were brought through the same Shelby County grand jury process, underscoring how TennCare fraud complaints from insurers like UnitedHealthcare continue to funnel into state criminal investigations targeting home care billing.