Indianapolis/ Food & Drinks
Published on November 01, 2019
The 5 best Italian spots in IndianapolisMama Carolla's | Photo: Niki B./Yelp

In search of a new favorite Italian spot?

Hoodline crunched the numbers to find the top Italian spots around Indianapolis, using both Yelp data and our own secret sauce to produce a ranked list of where to satisfy your cravings.

Indianapolis-area consumers tend to spend more in November at restaurants than other months of the year, according to data on local business transactions from Womply, a provider of online reputation management and business health for small businesses. The average amount spent per customer transaction at Indianapolis-area restaurants rose to $23 for the metro area in November of last year, second only to December with an average of $25 and 4% higher than the average for the rest of the year.

Hoodline offers data-driven analysis of local happenings and trends across cities. Links included in this article may earn Hoodline a commission on clicks and transactions.


1. Greek’s Pizzeria

Photo: noelle l./Yelp

First on the list is Greek’s Pizzeria. Located at 1601 Columbia Ave. in Martindale-Brightwood, the Italian spot, which offers pizza and more, is the highest-rated Italian restaurant in Indianapolis, boasting five stars out of 59 reviews on Yelp.

2. Mama Carolla's

Photo: Tara Q./Yelp

Next up is Fairgrounds's Mama Carolla's, situated at 1031 E. 54th St. With four stars out of 523 reviews on Yelp, the Italian spot has proven to be a local favorite.

3. Nesso

Photo: Jeff H./Yelp

Nesso, an Italian spot located downtown, is another much-loved go-to, with 4.5 stars out of 128 Yelp reviews. Head over to 339 S. Delaware St. to see for yourself.

4. Iozzo's Garden of Italy

Photo: Aaron W./Yelp

Downtown, check out Iozzo's Garden of Italy, which has earned four stars out of 418 reviews on Yelp. You can find the Italian spot at 946 S. Meridian St.

5. Vito Provolone's

Photo: Libbie V./Yelp

Last but not least, there's Vito Provolone's, a Hill Valley favorite with 4.5 stars out of 122 reviews. Stop by 8031 S. Meridian St. to hit up the Italian spot, which offers pizza and more, the next time the urge strikes.


This story was created automatically using local business data, then reviewed and augmented by an editor. Click here for more about what we're doing. Got thoughts? Go here to share your feedback.