Craving pizza?
Hoodline crunched the numbers to find the best affordable pizza outlets in Indianapolis, using both Yelp data and our own secret sauce to produce a ranked list of the best spots to meet your needs.
1. Magoo's California Pizza
Topping the list is Eagledale's Magoo's California Pizza, situated at 4919 W. 38th St. With 4.5 stars out of 141 reviews on Yelp, the fast-food spot, which offers pizza and more, has proven to be a local favorite for those looking for an affordable option.
Yelper Frankin B., who reviewed Magoo's California Pizza on Sept. 15, wrote, "Just moved to the area and I'm scouting for all the local spots. As for the taste of the pizza, great. We will be coming back for sure. The freshness of the tomato on the savory chicken Tikki is a nice touch. I liked that the garlic butter sauce was very complimentary for the crust."
Raymond M. noted, "Magoo's Chicken Tikka pizza is the absolute perfect pizza."
2. MOD Pizza
Keystone at the Crossing's location of the well-known chain MOD Pizza, located at 8505 Keystone Crossing, is another top choice, with Yelpers giving the affordable fast food spot, which offers pizza and more, 4.5 stars out of 103 reviews.
The site can tell you a thing or two more about MOD Pizza.
"MOD Pizza excites us because the focus is on taking care of our employees who will, in turn, take care of our communities," per the bio section of its Yelp profile. "In the restaurant biz, this is refreshing and empowering. We serve pizza to serve people!"
In terms of signature items, "MOD Pizza specializes in individual artisan-style pizzas Made On Demand (MOD) in a fast, friendly and stylish environment," it states on Yelp in the section explaining specialties. "All pizzas are cooked by hand in an 800-degree display oven and ready in under 5 minutes with as many toppings as you like for one low price."
3. Goodfellas Pizzeria
Goodfellas Pizzeria, a bar that offers pizza and more located downtown, is another cheap go-to, with four stars out of 290 Yelp reviews. Head over to 545 Massachusetts Ave. to see for yourself.
Yelper Sydney H., who reviewed Goodfellas Pizzeria on Dec. 10, wrote, "Goodfellas is the perfect stop for crispy, thin-crust pizza. I recommend sticking with one of their slices that you can buy straight from the case."
Yelper Patricia Abigail Y. wrote, "I went here after a concert at the Old National, we were hungry and my boyfriend and I got two pizzas, one breadstick with cheese and one soda for $14. That's cheap!"
4. Manhattan Pizzeria
And then there's Manhattan Pizzeria, a North High School favorite with 4.5 stars out of 67 reviews. Stop by 6225 W. 56th St. to hit up the spot to score pizza and more next time you're in the mood for cheap eats.
Yelper Kara M., who reviewed Manhattan Pizzeria on Sept. 2 wrote, "Reading some of the reviews of Manhattan Pizzeria I noticed some native New Yorkers said this pizza made them reminisce about the famous NY pizza they remember. If native New Yorkers give it a thumbs up then you know it's good."
Soraya G. noted, "Tasty pizza, friendly service, and with good prices. I could never tell you what's really NY style, never been, but I'll tell you the pizza is good! Crunchy crust, little oregano and it's thin."
This story was created automatically using local business data, then reviewed and augmented by an editor. Click here for more about what we're doing. Got thoughts? Go here to share your feedback.
