Indianapolis

Fishers Police Hunt for Suspect Cornelius Anthony Lyles Accused in Facebook Marketplace Armed Robbery

AI Assisted Icon
Published on October 10, 2025
Fishers Police Hunt for Suspect Cornelius Anthony Lyles Accused in Facebook Marketplace Armed RobberySource: Facebook/Fishers Police Department

The Fishers Police Department is currently on the search for a man named Cornelius Anthony Lyles, who is now facing multiple charges after an alleged robbery. The robbery involved a transaction arranged through Facebook Marketplace that took a dangerous turn when the suspect reportedly took out a weapon. According to the Fishers Police Department's Facebook post, Lyles is wanted on charges of armed robbery, intimidation, and theft related to the incident that occurred on August 15.

During the encounter, Lyles allegedly displayed a handgun to the victim and is claimed to have firmly stated his intention to take the listed item while threatening the victim's life if they were to resist. Following the altercation, Lyles is accused of stealing both the item up for sale and the victim's phone. The police were able to recover the discarded phone later, revealing fingerprints that belonged to both the victim and Lyles, as detailed by the Fishers Police Department's forensic unit.

The specific charges Lyles faces comprise a third-degree felony for armed robbery (F3), a fifth-degree felony for intimidation (F5), and a sixth-degree felony for theft (F6). With the seriousness of these allegations and the potential danger posed by Lyles, the Fishers Police Department is urging the public not to approach him if they happen to come across his whereabouts.

Anyone with information regarding Cornelius Anthony Lyles is encouraged to maintain a safe distance and should immediately call 911. Alternatively, tips can be directed to Detective Dean Mucha at 317-595-3330.