Indianapolis

Two-Decade-Old Owen County Cold Case Cracked, Deanna Smith Identified Through DNA Evidence

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 13, 2025
Two-Decade-Old Owen County Cold Case Cracked, Deanna Smith Identified Through DNA EvidenceSource: Google Street View

After more than two decades of mystery and investigation, the skeletal remains of an unidentified woman discovered in 2003 have been conclusively identified through the use of DNA evidence, bringing a modicum of closure to a haunting cold case from Owen County, Indiana. According to the FOX59 report, the Indiana State Police (ISP) announced that the body was that of a woman believed to be between 36 and 40 years old at her time of death, previously only known as Owen County Jane Doe (2003).

The turning point in this long-unsolved case came when investigators partnered with Othram, a company specializing in forensic genealogy, allowing them to develop a DNA profile that led to the matching of relatives who provided crucial DNA samples. The findings, as detailed on DNASolves.com, contributed to the positive identification of the woman as Deanna Smith, who had carried a medallion inscribed with endearing words and patriotic motifs – symbols that, despite their suggestiveness, had not led to her identification until now, and these details had been entered into the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs) with hopes that someday, someone would recognize them and lead investigators to her true identity.

The Owen County Coroner's Office, alongside the Indiana State Police Laboratory, collaborated extensively to remedy two decades of silence wrapped around the fate of Smith. Her remains had been found in a secluded, wooded ravine, an area poised for residential development but instead became the site of a profound mystery, capturing the attention of multiple law enforcement agencies committed to unveiling the truth behind her unwanted seclusion.

While the identification marks a significant breakthrough, the ISP maintains the investigation into Smith's death as an active homicide case, extending an open call for public assistance to further unravel the circumstances that led to Smith’s demise. Detective Toni Walden and Detective Matt Busick of the ISP Cold Case Unit are in charge of uncovering any new information Smith’s death, so they encourage anyone with knowledge of the crime or Smith's history to contact the ISP Evansville Post.