Chicago

Dunning Card Shop Robbed, $100K Stolen

AI Assisted Icon
Published on April 20, 2026
Dunning Card Shop Robbed, $100K StolenSource: Google Street View

An early-morning smash-and-grab left a Dunning sports-card, and comics shop nearly cleaned out Monday, after burglars shattered the storefront and made off with about $100,000 in graded cards, rare comics, and other collectibles, according to the owner. The hit has shaken local collectors and small business owners, who say soaring card prices have turned small hobby shops into especially tempting targets.

Chicago police said the break-in happened at 1:54 a.m., when two suspects shattered the front of Elite Sports Cards and Comics at 3406A N. Harlem Ave., grabbed merchandise, and fled in an unknown vehicle. Grand Central Area detectives were on scene early Monday and opened an investigation, according to CBS Chicago.

Shop Owner And Neighborhood Context

Elite Sports Cards and Comics is one of two shops run by owner Ronnie Holloway, and the Dunning location has been a neighborhood fixture for years, as reported by the Chicago Sun-Times. The store is known for high-value autographs and graded singles that can be particularly attractive to thieves, a mix that owners say makes serious security measures less of a luxury and more of a requirement.

Smash-And-Grab Trend Hitting Hobby Shops

Across the country, hobby shops have been hit by a wave of similar raids this winter and spring, with thieves in some cases walking away with tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars in cards and sealed product, an analysis by Sports Illustrated found. Investigative reporting for KWQC's InvestigateTV has linked the rise in these thefts to booming card values and organized operations that can quickly move stolen merchandise.

Police Response

Police said there were no immediate arrests after the early-morning break-in, and detectives continued canvassing the area for security camera footage and witnesses, per CBS Chicago. Officials have not released suspect descriptions or any details about the getaway vehicle.

How Collectors And Shops Respond

Dealers and collectors often push back by sharing images, serial numbers, and detailed descriptions of stolen items with other shops and grading databases, a tactic meant to make hot merchandise harder to fence, investigators and hobby experts say. Local owners say they are revisiting security setups and relying on the tight-knit collecting community to flag anyone trying to unload high-value cards in the area, according to KWQC's InvestigateTV.