
Chicago police cited officer safety and the need to verify information when explaining their approach to firearm-search warrants under Karina’s Law, according to the Chicago Sun-Times. The department said it does not refuse warrants and aims to recover weapons as safely as possible. A review of documents by the newspaper found that police had received at least 91 warrants under the law but had executed three.
Each of the three Chicago searches recovered multiple firearms, the Sun-Times reported. Police found two guns in a July 2025 case involving a protective order, four in an October 2025 divorce proceeding and 26 at a Bridgeport home in July 2026. In the Bridgeport case, the man facing domestic battery charges was already in custody when officers searched his home.
At a city budget hearing, Chicago Police Counterterrorism Chief Christopher Papaioannou said the law’s short deadlines can leave officers little time to verify details, assess risks and decide how to proceed, according to the Sun-Times. He said officers had done very well on the warrants they carried out and that many guns were obtained through voluntary surrender rather than searches.
Legal Aid Chicago managing attorney Benna Crawford told the Sun-Times that Chicago police had not executed warrants in cases brought by more than 30 of her clients. She said officers often returned to court seeking to cancel warrants, citing older information or uncertainty. By contrast, Crawford said, warrants her clients obtained for suburban police agencies were served and guns recovered in each search. The Sun-Times also reported that Crawford and Maralea Negron of The Network: Advocating Against Domestic Violence had not received a response to requests to meet with Chicago police.
The law sets different deadlines depending on whether the survivor recently filed a police report: officers have 96 hours to execute a warrant in the former circumstance, or 48 hours to investigate and bring concerns to a judge in the latter. The statute took effect statewide on May 11, 2025, and authorizes judges granting orders of protection to issue firearm search-and-seizure warrants, as described by the Sun-Times.
Warrant safeguards and firearm-removal research
The Network: Advocating Against Domestic Violence’s Karina’s Law guide says a firearm search warrant requires probable cause. It says a court may issue an emergency firearm remedy without first notifying the respondent only if the court finds that giving prior notice is likely to cause harm. A separate study summarized by the National Institute of Justice analyzed 580 domestic-violence protection-order filings. Judges granted firearm removal in 50.1 percent of cases in which petitioners requested it and received an order.
The law is named for Karina Gonzalez, who was killed with her 15-year-old daughter, Daniela, in July 2023 after Gonzalez had reported that her husband, Jose Alvarez, threatened her. She had an order of protection barring him from possessing a gun, but the weapon was not taken away, the Sun-Times reported. Their son, Manny Alvarez, has advocated for the law.
Cook County figures offer a wider view of the law’s early use. In its first year, 148 gun-seizure warrants were issued under the statute, 70 were dismissed and 58 guns were taken away, according to CBS News Chicago. Before the law, the county clerk granted 85 such warrants over a decade, while nearly 112,000 emergency protection orders were issued, the station reported.
State Sen. Celina Villanueva, a chief sponsor of the law, told the Sun-Times that the low number of Chicago searches was a problem and lawmakers should reconsider how to protect survivors. Negron said that failing to carry out warrants approved by judges undermines the law’s purpose.









