
Tulip Tree Creamery, the artisan cheesemaker that has become a fixture at farmers markets, stores and restaurants across central Indiana, is officially up for sale. Owners Fons Smits and Laura Davenport have decided to sell the business nearly 13 years after launching it, and they're now searching for someone willing to carry on its cheesemaking tradition.
According to IndyStar, Smits and Davenport cited both economic and personal reasons for putting their northwest-side creamery on the market. The company operates an in-house retail shop at 6330 Corporate Drive in Indianapolis and distributes its cheeses to farmers markets and restaurants throughout central Indiana as well as to stores nationwide.
Beyond the sale itself, the two outlets diverge on where production currently stands. IndyStar's report states that Tulip Tree has paused production, while WISH-TV reported that the creamery anticipated temporarily shutting down production at its Indianapolis facility on Dec. 31, 2026. Whether production has already stopped or is still winding down toward that date was not resolved between the two accounts.
What Happens to the Shop and Remaining Cheese
Per the same IndyStar report, the retail shop is expected to remain open through Dec. 23, 2026, giving customers a few more weeks to stop in before the holidays. Tulip Tree also plans to sell its remaining cheese inventory by the end of the year, and the company says it will share information about local outlets still carrying its cheese for the rest of 2026.
WISH-TV's report adds that anyone holding unused gift certificates, including those for cheese or for the creamery's classes, is encouraged to redeem them as soon as possible. Davenport told the station that the goal is to find a new owner and begin the business's next chapter in the first quarter of 2027, though whether production will resume at full scale depends on whether a buyer steps forward, per IndyStar's reporting.
From Startup to Award-Winning Creamery
Smits and Davenport founded Tulip Tree Creamery in 2014, bringing collective experience from award-winning creameries in Indiana, Illinois, Idaho and California, according to IndyStar. The pair split the work in a way that played to their strengths: Davenport, a Certified Cheese Professional through the American Cheese Society, has primarily handled sales and marketing, while Smits has overseen the actual cheesemaking.
The couple said their customers and farming partners made it possible for them to produce artisan cheeses and feel part of a thriving local food community. A 2019 profile from Cheese Connoisseur noted that the creamery was making 10 different cheeses at the time, including varieties like Foxglove, a double-cream cheese; Snapdragon, laced with habanero; and Milkweed, a Gruyère-inspired wheel.
A Track Record of National Recognition
Tulip Tree's cheeses have picked up recognition well beyond Indiana over the years. The creamery's own account, posted on its company website, lists a 2016 American Cheese Society award for its Nettle cheese, placements for Trillium in 2017, 2018 and 2019, and a 2022 silver award for Queen Anne's Lace. The same source notes that Tulip Tree products have been sold through select supermarkets, gourmet shops, wine and cheese shops, and butcher shops across the country, in addition to weekly farmers markets in Indiana.
For now, the creamery's future rests on finding a buyer willing to pick up where Smits and Davenport leave off. Until then, longtime customers have a narrowing window to visit the Corporate Drive shop, use up any lingering gift certificates, and stock up on cheese before the year's inventory runs out.









