Phoenix/ Crime & Emergencies

Arizona Abuse Survivors Take Mormon Church Shield Case to US Supreme Court

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Arizona Abuse Survivors Take Mormon Church Shield Case to US Supreme CourtArizona Supreme Court — Source of Challenged Ruling
Google Street View

Three survivors of Paul Adams’ sexual abuse are asking the U.S. Supreme Court to step in after the Arizona Supreme Court ruled that the First Amendment shields the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints from civil liability for failing to report what Adams confessed to two of its bishops. Adams, a Customs and Border Patrol officer in Bisbee, died by suicide in jail before he could stand trial. Neither bishop who heard his confession reported it to law enforcement.

Attorneys for the three victims have formally appealed to the nation’s highest court, arguing the Arizona Supreme Court misapplied the First Amendment by letting religious doctrine exempt clergy from the state’s mandatory child abuse reporting law, according to court documents cited by News 4 Tucson. The attorneys contend the ruling effectively turns a neutral child abuse reporting statute into an unconstitutional carve-out for religious organizations. Attorney Lynne Cadigan, who along with John Trebone has represented the survivors pro bono for years, said the Supreme Court should clarify that religious freedom does not permit concealing child rape, according to azfamily.com, which described the petition as a “Hail Mary” plea for the justices to hear the case.

How the Abuse Came to Light

Adams confessed to two bishops of the LDS Church that he was sexually abusing his children, per court documents referenced by News 4 Tucson, though accounts differ on when that first confession occurred. The Arizona Mirror reports Adams confessed to Bishop John Herrod in 2010 and that Herrod called a church “abuse help line,” which told him not to mention the abuse to any authorities, according to the Arizona Mirror. Religion News Service instead dates that confession to Bishop Herrod of the Bisbee Ward Mormon church to late 2011, reporting that Adams disclosed he had sexually abused his 5-year-old daughter, per Religion News Service.

Federal authorities discovered online video evidence of the abuse in 2017, leading to Adams’ arrest, according to court documents cited by News 4 Tucson. The Arizona Mirror similarly reports that Adams was arrested in 2017 after posting videos of himself abusing his children online. He died by suicide in jail before his case went to trial, and his wife, Leizza, was later sentenced to two and a half years in prison for child abuse, per the same azfamily.com account.

Children Later Sued, But Records Conflict on the Year

Three of Adams’ children eventually sued the church over its failure to report the abuse, though sources disagree on exactly when. The Salt Lake Tribune reports the lawsuit was filed in 2020, while the Arizona Mirror’s account places the filing in 2021. Either way, the case wound through Arizona’s courts for years before reaching the state’s highest bench.

The Arizona Supreme Court issued a unanimous ruling in favor of the church on July 30, 2026, finding that the First Amendment bars a jury from evaluating whether the bishops followed their own religious doctrine when they chose not to report the abuse, according to the Arizona Mirror. The court held that the First Amendment prevents judges and juries from second-guessing clergy decisions to withhold abuse reports when those decisions are considered reasonable and necessary under religious tenets, per court documents cited by News 4 Tucson. The ruling reversed a July 2025 Court of Appeals decision that would have allowed the children’s civil lawsuit to proceed to trial, sending the case back to lower courts, according to the Salt Lake Tribune.

Attorneys Push Back, Citing Constitutional Conflict

The victims’ attorneys argue the Arizona ruling conflicts with established constitutional principles, contending it improperly shields religious institutions from accountability under a reporting law meant to apply to everyone. Attorney John Manly said the Arizona Supreme Court’s opinion endangers the rights and safety of Arizona children and families, and that the U.S. Supreme Court must step in to protect the children, per court documents cited by News 4 Tucson.

Arizona law itself draws a narrow line around clergy communications. Under Arizona Revised Statutes § 13-3620, the exemption from mandatory reporting applies only to a communication or confession — not to personal observations a clergy member or other listed religious practitioner might separately make of a minor. The survivors’ attorneys say that distinction underscores why they believe the state court’s reading of the First Amendment went too far.

A Broader Shift Away From Clergy Exemptions

The case lands amid a wider national reckoning over clergy reporting exemptions. Six states — New Hampshire, North Carolina, Oklahoma, West Virginia, Rhode Island and Texas — have already eliminated the clergy clause from their mandatory reporting laws entirely, according to azfamily.com. Whether the U.S. Supreme Court agrees to hear the Arizona case remains an open question, one the justices have not yet addressed.