Western New York/ Real Estate & Development

Batavia Taco Bell Developer Strikes Deal for Castilone Lot, Widens West Main Footprint

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Batavia Taco Bell Developer Strikes Deal for Castilone Lot, Widens West Main FootprintMontclair Ave. — Approximate Street With Access Concerns
Google Street View

The developer behind a new Taco Bell planned for 244-248 West Main Street in Batavia has negotiated to purchase the adjacent lot at the corner of West Main and North Lyon streets from the owner of Castilone Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram, a move that could significantly expand the footprint of the long-contested project. The larger combined site would allow for more green space and additional access points, according to reporting on the deal.

Mike Pettinella, writing for The Daily News, reported Monday that the newspaper had learned of the negotiated purchase. The developer plans to build a new Taco Bell at 244-248 West Main St., the former Timebuyer property, and according to APD Engineering Architecture, the project would relocate the existing restaurant at 413 West Main Street to that site. (A separate account cited by The Daily News instead places the current Taco Bell at 212 West Main Street, a discrepancy that remains unresolved.)

A Bigger Site, A New Layout

Mike McCracken said combining the properties would create a larger site with more green space and access spread across three locations rather than concentrated solely on Montclair Avenue, the same report notes. He added that the approved plan could still be built as originally proposed, but that acquiring the adjacent parcel opens the door to either an amended approval or an entirely new site plan package.

According to McCracken, the second parcel would improve overall site flow, loosen up drive aisles, add parking, and increase green space — benefits he said would extend to the city, area residents, and neighbors along Montclair Avenue. Montclair Avenue itself runs north-south beside the former Timebuyer site at 244-248 West Main St.

Traffic Routing Has Shifted Repeatedly

The project's access plans have changed more than once as the proposal moved through local review. At a concept review in July, the applicant said customers and delivery trucks would enter and exit on Montclair Avenue, with only vehicles leaving the drive-thru exiting onto West Main Street, according to Video News Service. A later concept update described by APD Engineering Architecture kept that same Montclair Avenue entry and exit arrangement for customers and delivery vehicles, while again allowing drive-thru traffic a separate exit onto West Main Street.

The newly discussed proposal would add an access point on West Main likely configured as right-in, right-out, with right-in access located in the center of the block, while limiting Montclair Avenue access to a single driveway instead of two. A driveway on North Lyon Street is also included in the new proposal. The current approved site plan has a right-turn-only exit onto West Main Street.

McCracken said the redesigned layout would spread out traffic and let customers returning to the traffic light at West Main and North Lyon make a safer left-hand turn. He also said he expects most traffic would come off Main Street and return to Main Street.

Neighbors and the County Have Pushed Back

Not everyone is convinced the changes solve the underlying worries. Montclair Avenue neighbors have expressed concern that truck and car traffic could cut through their residential neighborhood regardless of how driveways are rearranged.

The Genesee County Planning Board had already recommended disapproval of the relocation as proposed, with the board stating that “the proposed site design inadequately addresses setbacks and buffers to the adjacent residential neighborhood,” per The Batavian. A Montclair Avenue resident separately questioned whether the traffic study used to support the project — completed in the summer — properly accounted for school-year bus pickups and drop-offs, since it was not conducted during the school year.

Approvals So Far, With More Review Ahead

Despite the county's reservations, Batavia's Planning and Development Committee approved the Taco Bell project at its October 20 meeting after the completed traffic study was reviewed. Days later, the city's Zoning Board of Appeals approved separate variance requests for the project following what was described as an uncoordinated State Environmental Quality Review process, the Video News Service report states.

The project still requires further review by the Genesee County Planning Board, which is scheduled to meet December 10, with the city Planning and Development Committee set to take the matter up again December 15. An updated concept presented by APD Engineering Architecture had called for 22 parking spaces, perimeter landscaping, and service areas at the rear of the property, though it remains unclear whether that configuration reflects the newly negotiated two-parcel site.

A Years-Long Effort to Relocate

The push to move Batavia's Taco Bell has a long and uneven history. Hospitality Syracuse Inc., which owns the Batavia Taco Bell, had previously hoped to shift the restaurant to the former Batavia Marine & Sporting Supply site next door, but that plan fell through. The company has described the broader relocation effort as a three- to five-year investment.

Taco Bell operates roughly 8,000 locations across seven states, with about 400 of those restaurants in New York State alone, underscoring the scale of the chain even as a single Batavia location works its way through a long municipal approval process.