
Bedford County's Board of Zoning Appeals has denied appeals from landowners fighting enforcement action over two properties that neighbors say have operated as illegal rock quarries for years, not the cattle ponds the owners claim they're building. The board upheld the county's enforcement actions, keeping in place a decision that treats the digging on land along Highway 64 and Fairfield Pike as mining and quarrying rather than routine farm work.
The board heard appeals from landowners affected by its September vote, according to NewsChannel 5, which first reported the denial. That September decision had already overturned an administrative finding that treated the excavation work as agriculture, and this latest ruling denied the landowners' appeal of that reversal along with their appeal of a stop-work order issued for the Fairfield Pike property. Property owners have separately challenged the board's decision in chancery court, per the same outlet's reporting.
Neighbors have reported dust, noise and blasting impacts from the two properties for three years, the station's report states. Jonathan O'Neal, one of the residents pushing back, said he and others would not stop resisting the activities despite meetings he described as intended to wear them down, according to NewsChannel 5's earlier coverage of the dispute.
Foundation Damage and a Years-Long Fight
In that earlier report, neighbors described mining and quarrying happening on two agriculturally zoned properties while the owners insisted they were digging ponds for cattle, as NewsChannel 5 reported. O'Neal told the station his household had spent roughly $3,000 to $5,000 on foundation repairs tied to the impacts. Neighbors believed the mining and quarrying operation had been going on for three years, though the Nashville Scene reported the landowners, identified as Hawkins and Price, a construction company, and Matthew Allen, owner of a trucking firm, had run unpermitted quarries on these properties for two years — accounts that differ on the timeline.
The two outlets also diverge on exactly when a stop-work order landed. NewsChannel 5 reported the county issued an actual stop-work order late in the day on September 28, with the property owners appealing it, while the Nashville Scene reported that Planning Director Chris White sent a stop-work order out the day after the board's September 17 vote. Bedford County Planning Director Chris White estimated the Highway 64 project was 30% complete, according to NewsChannel 5's reporting.
A September Vote That Set It All Off
The underlying fight traces back to that September 17 meeting, when the board voted 4-1 to overturn White's decision, according to the Nashville Scene, effectively ruling that the quarries were no longer being treated as ponds. At the recent hearing, some attendees urged the board to deny the landowners' appeals, while others supported the landowners, who said they were building ponds for cattle, per NewsChannel 5's account. Resident Brooke Sanders said modern agriculture looks different than it did decades ago and argued the state's right-to-farm law protects it, the station reported.
That law was central to the landowners' defense. The Nashville Scene reported that the landowners invoked the Tennessee Right to Farm Act, which the outlet described as allowing owners of A1 agricultural property to make farm improvements — including a livestock pond — without needing zoning approval or permits.
Part of a Wider Quarry Fight Statewide
Bedford County isn't the only Tennessee community wrestling with where quarries belong. The Nashville Scene reported on a state legislative proposal that would empower local governments to approve the location of any quarry or digital asset mining facility in a public meeting, a measure that could also require reports on potential harm to residents or the environment. The same outlet reported that residents near Grundy County's Clouse Hill Sand Quarry have complained of loud explosions and worried the blasting threatens their well water.
A similar standoff is unfolding in Moore County, where the Metro Board of Zoning Appeals recently declined to rule either way on a special-exception request from Lynchburg Stone LLC for a quarry along Highway 50. The Lynchburg Times reported the board voted 3-0 to postpone its decision while it waits on legal advice, with no motion made to approve or deny the request. For Bedford County residents like O'Neal, the chancery court challenge now filed by the property owners means the ponds-or-quarries fight is far from settled.









