Indianapolis/ Community & Society

Beech Grove Monastery Shrinks From 160 Sisters to 40, Builds Anew

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 22, 2026
Beech Grove Monastery Shrinks From 160 Sisters to 40, Builds AnewEnvive Healthcare of Beech Grove — Former Hermitage Funding Source
Google Street View

Our Lady of Grace Monastery in Beech Grove has spent 71 years on the same patch of land at 1402 Southern Ave., and this year the Benedictine sisters who live there moved into a brand-new, smaller building to replace the aging one that stood in its place. The community that once numbered roughly 160 sisters now counts just 40, yet every one of the new building's 36 rooms is occupied.

That decline, and the new facility built to match it, were detailed in a report from Mirror Indy, which was republished by Free Press Indiana and carried locally by The Republic. The monastery, founded in 1955 after swampland was transformed into the site, is Indianapolis' only monastery of women, according to the report. Beech Grove Mayor Jim Coffman told Mirror Indy the sisters dedicate their lives to helping people in Beech Grove and the greater region.

A Smaller Building for a Smaller Community

The old monastery building had become a liability rather than a sanctuary. Per the same account, the original structure contained asbestos and lacked central air conditioning and other modern amenities, pushing the sisters toward the costly decision to rebuild rather than renovate. The old building was ultimately demolished to make way for a parking lot and more trees on the property, the report noted.

Paying for the new building required a mix of resources. The sisters used existing funds, profit from selling their healthcare clinic, and about $7 million raised separately to cover the project, the outlet reported. That clinic sale closed in 2022, the same report states, years after the Sisters of St. Benedict had founded St. Paul Hermitage retirement and nursing care, which began accepting residents in 1962 and expanded in 1997. St. Paul Hermitage now operates under the name Envive Healthcare of Beech Grove with different owners, according to the same account.

Prioress Julie Sewell, who leads the sisters, said owning only one nursing home is no longer financially viable in the industry, the report states. Mirror Indy noted the nuns sold St. Paul Hermitage partly because of declining numbers of sisters, changing medical policies during the COVID-19 pandemic, and the financial feasibility of running a standalone clinic.

Grief and Gratitude Inside the New Walls

The move has not been without loss. Two sisters died after moving into the new building earlier this year, according to the report. Still, residents describe the new space in warm terms — Vivian Bailey said the new monastery felt like home again, Mirror Indy reported, while the building itself retains artwork, sculptures and organ pipes transferred from the old structure, and now includes a gym, music room and hair salon.

The monastery's cemetery holds about 95 buried sisters, a quiet record of generations who lived there before this one, per the same account. Sister Mary Luke Jones, who has been with the monastery for 60 years, said the religious life is less appealing to women today than it was in the 1950s, according to the report.

One Sister's Winding Path to Beech Grove

Sister Marie Racine's journey to the monastery illustrates how differently a vocation can arrive. She worked as a software engineer in Massachusetts for 17 years before beginning to discern a religious calling in the late 1990s, the report states. She visited Our Lady of Grace Monastery in October 1999 and moved there the following year, turning 40 years old the day after she arrived, according to Mirror Indy. She said she felt God was disrupting her wonderful life, the outlet reported.

The Sisters of St. Benedict trace their roots to Europe, having immigrated to the United States in the 1840s and settled in Pennsylvania before the Beech Grove community took shape over a century later, per the same account. The monastery has served residents over the decades through prayer, education, healthcare, community and private events, though it no longer operates its own school or nursing home. Our Lady of Grace Academy closed in 1978 due to declining enrollment, the report noted, and the monastery has since converted part of its building into a retreat space for local community groups, businesses and schools.

National Numbers Mirror a Local Story

The shrinking Beech Grove community reflects a broader pattern documented nationally. According to the Global Sisters Report, citing CARA data, the U.S. Catholic sister population peaked in 1965 with 181,421 sisters and has since fallen by almost 73 percent to fewer than 50,000 today. The same report found there are more Catholic sisters in the U.S. older than 90 than there are younger than 60, though it also noted that 40 percent of those who entered religious life in the preceding ten years were of a race or ethnicity other than Caucasian.

Not every community is shrinking, however. Global Sisters Report pointed to the Dominican Sisters of the Congregation of St. Cecilia in Nashville as a counterexample, noting that community has grown 76 percent since 2000 — a reminder that the trend among religious communities varies widely even as the overall numbers decline.

In Beech Grove, the monastery's lay board of advisors, led by president Connie Lund, provides guidance on finances and space as the sisters settle into their new home, according to the report. The sisters held open houses over the past few months to share the building with the community, and Mass remains open to the public on Wednesdays at 5:15 p.m. and Sundays at 11 a.m.