Salt Lake City/ Crime & Emergencies

Box Elder Sheriff Charged With Lying About His Location During DUI Probe

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 12, 2026
Box Elder Sheriff Charged With Lying About His Location During DUI ProbeCache County Attorney’s Office — Office That Pursued Investigation
Google Street View

Box Elder County Sheriff Kevin Potter, 55, is charged with one count of obstruction of justice, a Class A misdemeanor, stemming from a January investigation into whether he was driving while impaired. The charge centers on what Potter allegedly told investigators about his whereabouts that evening, and whether cell phone location records later contradicted his account.

According to ABC4, Box Elder County Dispatch received a citizen report on January 17, 2026, at approximately 5:28 p.m. Around 5:39 p.m. that evening, a Utah Highway Patrol colonel contacted Potter, who refused to meet in person but agreed to speak by phone, per court documents cited by the outlet. Potter reportedly confirmed he had a beer can in his pocket but told the officer he was not impaired and was at his house in Brigham City.

A trooper and a Brigham City Police Department officer went to Potter's home to verify his account, but according to ABC4, they did not see his county-issued vehicle and did not see him return home during the two hours they remained in the area. Court documents say Potter's phone had pinged in the area of Tremonton until approximately 6:18 p.m. that evening, placing him away from the address he gave investigators.

Cache County Takes Over to Avoid Conflict

The Cache County Attorney's Office took over the investigation to avoid a conflict of interest and issued a search warrant for Potter's cell phone location data, ABC4 reported. The office also requested a follow-up investigation specifically to determine whether Potter had told the truth about being home, according to the same report. The case was later transferred to the Utah State Bureau of Investigation to complete that requested follow-up, as KUTV reported.

Verizon produced the warrant return records on September 15, and those records pinged Potter in the Tremonton area, according to the station's report. Court documents state there was probable cause to believe Potter intentionally provided false information to the colonel regarding his present physical location during the active DUI investigation, per the same account. Potter was charged with the Class A misdemeanor on Friday, November 6, KUTV reported.

Sheriff Remains on Leave After Fatal Crash

Potter had not been taken into custody at the time of ABC4's report. He is also currently on voluntary administrative leave following a separate, fatal motorcycle crash. That leave began after the October 27 collision, which critically injured a young woman on a motorcycle; she later died from her injuries.

An outside review connected to the January incident found insufficient evidence to support allegations that Potter had been driving under the influence of alcohol, ABC4 reported, though it did identify violations of county and sheriff's office policies. Potter was issued a public letter of censure during a County Commission meeting in May, according to the outlet. Utah Code section 76-8-306, titled Obstruction of justice in a criminal investigation or proceeding, is the statute under which the misdemeanor charge falls.