Salt Lake City/ Crime & Emergencies

Salt Lake City Lost Key Evidence in Two Indigenous Cold Case Murders

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Salt Lake City Lost Key Evidence in Two Indigenous Cold Case MurdersUintah and Ouray Reservation — Reservation Burns And Jack Left
Google Street View

Salt Lake City police have acknowledged that key evidence in two unsolved murders of Indigenous men — Cornell Burns and Larry Jack — was discarded years ago, leaving investigators with little physical material left to test against modern forensic tools. The admission comes as a newly launched remembrance database tries to fill gaps in how Utah tracks and tells the stories of its missing and murdered Indigenous people.

Burns, 23, was found on Kelsey Avenue near Liberty Park on May 18, 1990, with tire marks across his back; the coroner also found a gunshot wound to his head, according to The Salt Lake Tribune. Police collected blood and fiber evidence from tennis shoes brought to a repair shop after the murder. Salt Lake City police Sgt. Greg Wilking told the paper the bloodied shoe is simply gone now, apparently discarded years ago — in his words, “all that evidence was destroyed.”

Larry Jack, a 46-year-old member of the Ute Tribe who was homeless at the time of his death, was found murdered in 1985 with his throat cut in a downtown parking lot. Police recovered a bloodstained, brown-handled Buck knife from a man near his body, but that knife has also since been discarded, per Wilking's account to the Tribune. Salt Lake prosecutors chose to extradite that suspect to Montana rather than pursue a murder charge, the Tribune reported.

A Detective Still Chasing Leads

Two months after Burns' murder, police arrested a person of interest in the case on misdemeanor charges; that person later died in the early 2000s. An anonymous caller had alleged Burns was killed by a woman and three men following a dispute over drugs, though the case remains unsolved. A cold case detective is still seeking information from anyone who attended the party Burns was at the night he was killed, while the Utah Investigative Journalism Project says it has been unable to locate any living relatives of Larry Jack. Burns' own family members declined to comment for the story.

Both men came from the Uintah and Ouray Reservation in eastern Utah. Their deaths landed in a city reeling from a surge in violence: Salt Lake City recorded 25 homicides in 1990, a 77.3% increase over the average for the 1980s, according to the same Tribune report, as the city also moved into an early-1990s heroin boom.

A New Database Built Around Family Control

The gaps in these two cases are part of why a new project called Traces launched the week of November 16. Traces is described by MMIR Utah as its community-governed remembrance site for Missing and Murdered Indigenous Relatives connected to Utah, built as a collaboration between MMIR Utah, the University of Utah Department of Communication and the Utah Investigative Journalism Project. As of KSL's report, stories about 11 people had been posted to the site, according to KSL.com, which noted that the University of Utah Department of Communication funded the effort while the Utah Investigative Journalism Project helped research and write its initial stories.

Families and community members can use Traces to share information about a relative, request a correction or update, raise a cultural or safety concern, or ask that a page be reviewed or removed, per MMIR Utah's own description of the site. The organization says it prioritizes family-guided storytelling and records the permissions attached to each remembrance — meaning participants control what information they share and with whom, and can choose whether to opt into contact from journalists or cold case investigators at all. Tammy Dee Platero, co-founder and director of MMIR Utah, has said the project is built first on an Indigenous cultural framework rather than a traditional investigative one.

Why Utah's Numbers Remain Murky

The scale of the problem in Utah is still hard to pin down. A 2023 report cited by KSL found that American Indian and Alaska Native people make up just 1.6% of Utah's population but account for more than 5% of its murder victims. Years earlier, a 2021 investigation by KUTV found that Utah law enforcement and criminal justice officials admitted they did not know exactly how many missing and murdered Indigenous cases existed statewide, even as the state's Department of Public Safety had identified at least 15 cold cases involving Native American or Alaska Native victims and at least 25 additional cases of missing Indigenous women still under active investigation.

That data gap is not unique to Utah. The Urban Indian Health Institute began a national study in 2017 of missing and murdered American Indian and Alaska Native women and girls, producing a snapshot of 71 urban cities and concluding that reliable data on this violence remains scarce nationwide. Among the cases that study and later reporting surfaced is that of Shawn J. Manymules, who KUTV reported was shot and killed across the street from Pioneer Park in Salt Lake City on July 26, 2017 — a murder that remains unsolved.

Lost Evidence Beyond These Two Cases

The discarded evidence in the Burns and Jack cases is not an isolated lapse. A 2018 report from the Tribune found Salt Lake City police had identified missing items from 20 separate homicide investigations dating to the 1970s and early 1980s, including the knife used in the November 1978 stabbing death of Anthony Adams, which detectives said could not be retested with modern DNA methods because it had vanished from evidence. That earlier pattern underscores the stakes for families still waiting on answers decades later.

State lawmakers have tried, with mixed results, to address the broader crisis. The Utah Legislature created the Murdered and Missing Indigenous Women and Girls Task Force in 2020, and a 2023 task force document recommended training law enforcement and medical examiner staff on cultural issues specific to Tribal nations in Utah and improving communication and trust between agencies and tribal communities. Rep. Angela Romero proposed legislation this year to create a law-enforcement training curriculum specifically for investigating Indigenous murders and disappearances, but the measure did not pass.

Platero has said Utah lags behind states like New Mexico, which have built dedicated MMIR cold case units making greater progress on similar cases. For the families of Cornell Burns and Larry Jack, and for others whose cases sit in Utah's cold case files, Traces offers something the justice system has not: a place to be remembered, and a measure of control over how and whether their stories are told.